Commit Graph

39 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Jordan Hrycaj c0d580715e
Remodel persistent snapdb access (#1274)
* Re-model persistent database access

why:
  Storage slots healing just run on the wrong sub-trie (i.e. the wrong
  key mapping). So get/put and bulk functions now use the definitions
  in `snapdb_desc` (earlier there were some shortcuts for `get()`.)

* Fixes: missing return code, typo, redundant imports etc.

* Remove obsolete debugging directives from `worker_desc` module

* Correct failing unit tests for storage slots trie inspection

why:
  Some pathological cases for the extended tests do not produce any
  hexary trie data. This is rightly detected by the trie inspection
  and the result checks needed to adjusted.
2022-10-20 17:59:54 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 096d93ab31
Remove direct support for legacy pivot finder (#1272)
why:
  Not used anymore. The current finder is good enough based on the
  the reported best header and difficulty.
2022-10-19 15:03:55 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 85fdb61699
Prep for full sync after snap make 3 (#1270)
* For snap sync, publish `EthWireRef` in sync descriptor

why:
  currently used for noise control

* Detect and reuse existing storage slots

* Provide healing module for storage slots

* Update statistic ticker (adding range factor for unprocessed storage)

* Complete mere function for work item ranges

why:
  Merging interval into existing partial item was missing

* Show av storage queue lengths in ticker

detail;
  Previous attempt shows average completeness which did not tell much

* Correct the meaning of the storage counter (per pivot)

detail:
  Is the # accounts that have a storage saved
2022-10-19 11:04:06 +01:00
jangko 3fa1b012e6
initial wire protocol transformation
rework on the eth wire protocol handlers.
curently still missing 4 handlers implementation.
but the framework is ready for eexpansion.
2022-10-15 19:48:21 +07:00
Jordan Hrycaj 8c7d91512b
Prep for full sync after snap mark2 (#1263)
* Rename `LeafRange` => `NodeTagRange`

* Replacing storage slot partition point by interval

why:
  The partition point only allows to describe slots `[point,high(Uint256)]`
  for fetching interval slot ranges. This has been generalised for any
  interval.

* Replacing `SnapAccountRanges` by `SnapTrieRangeBatch`

why:
  Generalised healing status for accounts, and later for storage slots.

* Improve accounts healing loop

* Split `snap_db` into accounts and storage modules

why:
  It is cleaner to have separate session descriptors for accounts and
  storage slots (based on a common base descriptor.)

  Also, persistent storage handling might be changed in future which
  requires the storage slot implementation disentangled from the accounts
  handling.

* Re-model worker queues for storage slots

why:
  There is a dynamic list of storage sub-tries, each one has to be
  treated similar to the accounts database. This applied to slot
  interval downloads as well as to healing

* Compress some return value report lists for snapdb methods

why:
  No need to report all handling details for work items that are filteres
  out and discarded, anyway.

* Remove inner loop frame from healing function

why:
  The healing function runs as a loop body already.
2022-10-14 17:40:32 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj d53eacb854
Prep for full sync after snap (#1253)
* Split fetch accounts into sub-modules

details:
  There will be separated modules for accounts snapshot, storage snapshot,
  and healing for either.

* Allow to rebase pivot before negotiated header

why:
  Peers seem to have not too many snapshots available. By setting back the
  pivot block header slightly, the chances might be higher to find more
  peers to serve this pivot. Experiment on mainnet showed that setting back
  too much (tested with 1024), the chances to find matching snapshot peers
  seem to decrease.

* Add accounts healing

* Update variable/field naming in `worker_desc` for readability

* Handle leaf nodes in accounts healing

why:
  There is no need to fetch accounts when they had been added by the
  healing process. On the flip side, these accounts must be checked for
  storage data and the batch queue updated, accordingly.

* Reorganising accounts hash ranges batch queue

why:
  The aim is to formally cover as many accounts as possible for different
  pivot state root environments. Formerly, this was tried by starting the
  accounts batch queue at a random value for each pivot (and wrapping
  around.)

  Now, each pivot environment starts with an interval set mutually
  disjunct from any interval set retrieved with other pivot state roots.

also:
  Stop fishing for more pivots in `worker` if 100% download is reached

* Reorganise/update accounts healing

why:
  Error handling was wrong and the (math. complexity of) whole process
  could be better managed.

details:
  Much of the algorithm is now documented at the top of the file
  `heal_accounts.nim`
2022-10-08 18:20:50 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj eca5882238
Isolating sync action modules (#1249)
* Miscellaneous updates TBC

* Disentangled pivot2 module from snap

why:
  Wrote as template on top of sync so it can be shared by fast and snap
  sync.

* Renamed and relocated pivot sources

* Integrated `best_pivot` module into full and snap sync

why:
  Full sync used an older version of `best_pivot`

* isolating download module from full sync

why;
  might be shared with snap sync at a later stage
2022-09-30 09:22:14 +01:00
jangko 86f6d284aa
initial beacon sync skeleton implementation 2022-09-17 09:08:55 +07:00
jangko 513f44d7d4
add local copy of ethereum wire protocol spec 2022-09-17 09:08:55 +07:00
Jordan Hrycaj 4ff0948fed
Snap sync accounts healing (#1225)
* Added inspect module

why:
  Find dangling references for trie healing support.

details:
 + This patch set provides only the inspect module and some unit tests.
 + There are also extensive unit tests which need bulk data from the
   `nimbus-eth1-blob` module.

* Alternative pivot finder

why:
  Attempt to be faster on start up. Also tying to decouple pivot finder
  somehow by providing different mechanisms (this one runs in `single`
  mode.)

* Use inspect module for healing

details:
 + After some progress with account and storage data, the inspect facility
   is used to find dangling links in the database to be filled nose-wise.
 + This is a crude attempt to cobble together functional elements. The
   set up needs to be honed.

* fix scheduler to avoid starting dead peers

why:
  Some peers drop out while in `sleepAsync()`. So extra `if` clauses
  make sure that this event is detected early.

* Bug fixes causing crashes

details:

+ prettify.toPC():
  int/intToStr() numeric range over/underflow

+ hexary_inspect.hexaryInspectPath():
  take care of half initialised step with branch but missing index into
  branch array

* improve handling of dropped peers in alternaive pivot finder

why:
  Strange things may happen while querying data from the network.
  Additional checks make sure that the state of other peers is updated
  immediately.

* Update trace messages

* reorganise snap fetch & store schedule
2022-09-16 08:24:12 +01:00
andri lim ad4e25b27e
Fix eth66 and eth67 handshake (#1214)
* bump nim-eth

* fix eth66 and eth67 handshake
2022-09-05 23:37:58 +02:00
Jacek Sieka c2ed731fa5
eth: adapt to smaller eth_types (#1210) 2022-09-03 20:15:35 +02:00
Jordan Hrycaj 72a31593a9
Snap fetch account storage data (#1211)
* Removed database write comparison statistics

* Provide life storage tests data

details:
  database dumps on external repo `nimbus-eth1`-blobs`

* Update hexary tree interpolation for storage bulk tests

* fetch storage update
2022-09-02 19:16:09 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj de2c13e136
Update snap offline tests (#1199)
* Re-implemented `hexaryFollow()` in a more general fashion

details:
+ New name for re-implemented `hexaryFollow()` is `hexaryPath()`
+ Renamed `rTreeFollow()` as `hexaryPath()`

why:
  Returning similarly organised structures, the results of the
  `hexaryPath()` functions become comparable when running over
  the persistent and the in-memory databases.

* Added traversal functionality for persistent ChainDB

* Using `Account` values as re-packed Blob

* Repack samples as compressed data files

* Produce test data

details:
+ Can force pivot state root switch after minimal coverage.
+ For emulating certain network behaviour, downloading accounts stops for
  a particular pivot state root if 30% (some static number) coverage is
  reached. Following accounts are downloaded for a later pivot state root.
2022-08-24 14:44:18 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj f07945d37b
Misc snap sync updates (#1192)
* Bump nim-stew

why:
  Need fixed interval set

* Keep track of accumulated account ranges over all state roots

* Added comments and explanations to unit tests

* typo
2022-08-17 08:30:11 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 7489784ba8
Snap sync accounts db code reorg (#1189)
* Extracted functionality into sub-modules for maintainability

* Setting SST bulk load as default in `accounts_db`

details:
+ currently, the same data are stored via rocksdb if available, and
  the same via embedded `storage_type` with (non-standard) prefix 200
  for time comparisons
+ fallback to normal `put()` unless rocksdb is accessible
2022-08-15 16:51:50 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 7d7e26d45f
Experimental bulk loader tests (#1187)
why:
  Rocksdb bulk loading might provide a slight advantage when loading
  larger data sets into the system
2022-08-12 16:42:07 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 5f0e89a41e
Snap accounts bulk import preparer (#1183)
* Provided common scheduler API, applied to `full` sync

* Use hexary trie as storage for proofs_db records

also:
 + Store metadata with account for keeping track of account state
 + add iterator over accounts

* Common scheduler API applied to `snap` sync

* Prepare for accounts bulk import

details:
+ Added some ad-hoc checks for proving accounts data received from the
  snap/1 (will be replaced by proper database version when ready)
+ Added code that dumps some of the received snap/1 data into a file
  (turned of by default, see `worker_desc.nim`)
2022-08-04 09:04:30 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 73b628491d
Clique snapshots reorg (#1169)
* Add persistent snapshot size logging

why:
  Suspecting too much space used

snapshot statistic:
  [..]
  blockNumber=2214912 nSnaps=2236 snapsTotal=1.14m
  blockNumber=2215936 nSnaps=2237 snapsTotal=1.14m
  [..]
  Persisting blocks fromBlock=2216449 toBlock=2216640
  36458496	datadir-nimbus-goerlish/data/nimbus/

* Replace legacy `lru_cache` by `keyed_queue`

why:
  `keyed_queue` generalises `lru_cache`

snapshot statistic:
  [..]
  blockNumber=2234368 nSnaps=2259 snapsTotal=1.15m
  blockNumber=2235392 nSnaps=2260 snapsTotal=1.15m
  [..]
  Persisting blocks fromBlock=2235649 toBlock=2235840
  37627288	datadir-nimbus-goerlish/data/nimbus/

* Increase persistent snapshot storage interval by 300%

snapshot statistic:
      [..]
      blockNumber=2232320 nSnaps=620 snapsTotal=0.30m
      blockNumber=2236416 nSnaps=621 snapsTotal=0.30m
      [..]
      Persisting blocks fromBlock=2237185 toBlock=2237376
      37627288	datadir-nimbus-goerlish/data/nimbus/

* Cull legacy debugging environment for clique

why:
  Chronicles provides a better choice (when properly set up)
2022-07-21 19:16:28 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 5d98f68c09
Sync update to work with sepolia reorgs (#1168)
* Error return in `persistBlocks()` on initial `VmState` roblem

why:
  previously threw an exception

* Updated sync mode option

why:
 using enum rather than bool => space for more

* Added sync mode `full`, re-factued legacy sync

also:
  rebased

* Fix typo (crashes `pesistBlocks()` otherwise)

also:
  rebase to master

* Reduce log ticker noise by suppressing duplicate messages

* Clarify staged queue overflow handling

why:
  backtrack/re-org mode in `stageItem()` should be detected by both,
  the global indicator or the work item where it might have moved into.

also:
  rebased
2022-07-21 13:14:41 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 1a5e2e53dd
treat `persistBlocks()` exception as failure return code, unless `Defect` (#1155) 2022-07-06 16:00:51 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 134fe26997
Store proved snap accounts (#1145)
* Relocated `IntervalSets` to nim-stew repo

* Accumulate accounts on temporary kv-DB

why:
  Explore the data as returned from snap/1. Will be converted to a
  `eth/db` next.

details:
  Verify and accumulate per/state-root accounts downloaded via snap.

also:
  Some unit tests

* Replace `Table` by `TrieDatabaseRef` for accounts accumulator

* update ticker statistics

details:
  mean/variance based counter update

* allow persistent db for proved accounts

* rebase, and globally activate unit test

* fix statistics
2022-07-01 12:42:17 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj c123e1eb93
Updated account scheduler (#1124)
* Using `IntervalSet` type data for `LeafRange`

* Updated log ticker

* Update to `eth67`

details:
  Disabled by default, use `ENABLE_LEGACY_ETH66=0` to enable
  No support for `Get/NodeData` dialogue via eth, anymore

* Dissolved fetch/common.nim

details;
  the log/ticker part becomes ticker.nim
  the interval range management is merged into fetch.nim

* Updated account scheduler

why:
  The previous scheduler fetched each account once (for different state
  roots.) The updated scheduler re-calibrates after a change of the state
  root and potentially (until told otherwise) fetches all possible
  accounts.

* Fix `high(P)` fringe cases in `IntervalSet` handling

why:
  The `high(P)` value for a point type `P` cannot be represented with
  half open intervals `[a,b)` for a,b points of `P`. So this single value
  needs extra treatment which was slightly wrong.

* Updated docu/comments

also:
  rebased

* Update scheduler

details:
  Change the `pivot` management when creating new accounts lists. It is
  strictly increasing (and wrapping around) depending on last updated
  accounts list.
2022-06-16 09:58:50 +01:00
jangko a37f8b17e2
fix rpc and websocket server config if they share the same port with engine api
also fixes json-rpc-engine-api server and websocket-engine-api server shutdown code,
checking if they actually created or not at startup.

fix #1119
2022-06-13 19:32:19 +07:00
Jordan Hrycaj 76f6de8059
Normalise snap objects (#1114)
* Fix/recover download flag

why:
  The fetch indicator used to control the data download somehow got
  lost during re-org.

* Updated chronicles/logger topics

* Reorganised run state flags

why:
  The original code used a pair of boolean flags `(stopped,stopThisState)`
  which was translated to three states running, stoppedPending, and
  stopped. It is currently not clear whether collapsing some states was
  correct. So the original logic has been re-stored, albeit wrapped into
  directives like `isStopped()` etc.

also:
  Moving some function bodies in `worker.nim`

* Moved `reply_data.nim` and `validate_trienode.nim` to sub-directory `fetch_trie`

why:
  Only used in `fetch_trie.nim`.

* Move `fetch_*` file and directory objects to `fetch` subdirectory

why:
  Only used in `fetch.nim`

* Added start/stop and/or setup/release methods for all sub-modules

why:
  good housekeeping

also:
  updated getters/setters for ctrl states
  updated trace messages
2022-06-06 14:42:08 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 96bb09457e
Snap sync rename objects (#1099)
* Disentangle `collect` module from `reply_data`

why:
  Now the module visible from `collect` for fetching data is `peer/fetch`
  only.

* Merge `SnapPeerHunt` into `collect`

why:
  This part needs to be known by `collect`, only

* rename collect => worker

* Dissolve `sync_fetch_xdesc` module into `common`

why:
  Descriptor is only used in `common` and `fetch_trie`

* rename `snap/peer` directory => `snap/worker`

* rename `SnapSync` -> `Worker`, `SnapPeer` -> `WorkerBuddy`

* moved `snap/base_desc.nim` -> `snap/worker/worker_desc.nim`

* Unified opaque object ref naming in `worker_desc.nim`

details:
  indicated my inheriting module (exactly one, always)
2022-05-24 09:07:39 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj ba940a5ce7
Snap sync simplify object inheritance (#1098)
* Reorg SnapPeerBase descriptor, notably start/stop flags

details:
  Instead of using three boolean flags startedFetch, stopped, and
  stopThisState a single enum type is used with values SyncRunningOk,
  SyncStopRequest, and SyncStopped.

* Restricting snap to eth66 and later

why:
  Id-tracked request/response wire protocol can handle overlapped
  responses when requests are sent in row.

* Align function names with source code file names

why:
  Easier to reconcile when following the implemented logic.

* Update trace logging (want file locations)

why:
  The macros previously used hid the relevant file location (when
  `chroniclesLineNumbers` turned on.) It rather printed the file
  location of the template that was wrapping `trace`.

* Use KeyedQueue table instead of sequence

why:
  Quick access, easy configuration as LRU or FIFO with max entries
  (currently LRU.)

* Dissolve `SnapPeerEx` object extension into `SnapPeer`

why;
  It is logically cleaner and more obvious not to inherit from
  `SnapPeerBase` but to specify opaque field object references of the
  merged `SnapPeer` object. These can then be locally inherited.

* Dissolve `SnapSyncEx` object extension into `SnapSync`

why;
  It is logically cleaner and more obvious not to inherit from
  `SnapSyncEx` but to specify opaque field object references of
  the `SnapPeer` object. These can then be locally inherited.

  Also, in the re-factored code here the interface descriptor
  `SnapSyncCtx` inherited `SnapSyncEx` which was sub-optimal (OO
  inheritance makes it easier to work with call back functions.)
2022-05-23 17:53:19 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 575c69e6ba
Objects inheritance reorg for snap sync (#1091)
* new: time_helper, types

* new: path_desc

* new: base_desc

* Re-organised objects inheritance

why:
  Previous code used macros to instantiate opaque object references. This
  has been re-implemented with OO inheritance based logic.

* Normalised trace macros

* Using distinct types for Hash256 aliases

why:
  Better control of the meaning of the hashes, all or the same format

caveat:
  The protocol handler DSL used by eth66.nim and snap1.nim uses the
  underlying type Hash256 and cannot handle the distinct alias in
  rlp and chronicles/log macros. So Hash256 is used directly (does
  not change readability as the type is clear by parameter names.)
2022-05-17 12:09:49 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 62d31d6f1d
Normalise sync handler prototypes (#1087)
* Use type name eth and snap (rather than snap1)

* Prettified snap/eth handler trace messages

* Regrouped sync sources

details:
  Snap storage related sources are moved to common directory.
  Option --new-sync renamed to --snap-sync

also:
  Normalised logging for secondary/non-protocol handlers.

* Merge protocol wrapper files => protocol.nim

details:
  Merge wrapper sync/protocol_ethxx.nim and sync/protocol_snapxx.nim
  into single file snap/protocol.nim

* Comments cosmetics

* Similar start logic for blockchain_sync.nim and sync/snap.nim

* Renamed p2p/blockchain_sync.nim -> sync/fast.nim
2022-05-13 17:30:10 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 569d426ea8
Restore not waiting for fastBlockchainSync() to succeed on start up (#1077)
why:
  Accidentally wrapped into waitFor() directive with reviving jl/sync
  branch.

also:
  Decorate eth/66 and snap/1 protocol trace messages with protocol
  type and version
2022-05-10 09:02:34 +01:00
Jordan Hrycaj 58e0543920
Squashed snap-sync-preview patch (#1076)
* Squashed snap-sync-preview patch

why:
  Providing end results makes it easier to have an overview.

  Collected patch set comments are available as nimbus/sync/ChangeLog.md
  in chronological order, oldest first.

* Removed some cruft and obsolete imports, normalised logging
2022-05-09 15:04:48 +01:00
jangko f2f204293e
first step into styleCheck fixes 2022-04-14 08:39:50 +07:00
Jordan Hrycaj 046c97f18b
Activate wire protocol eth/66 (#993)
* Activate wire protocol eth/66

and:
 Disentangle protocol_eth66.nim from import sections

why:
  Importing the protocol_eth66 module is not necessary. There is
  no need to know too many details of the underlying wire protocol. All
  that is needed will be exported by blockchain_sync.nim.

* fixes, and rebase

* Update nimbus/p2p/blockchain_sync.nim

Co-authored-by: Kim De Mey <kim.demey@gmail.com>

* Fixes and rebase

Co-authored-by: Kim De Mey <kim.demey@gmail.com>
2022-03-21 17:12:07 +00:00
bmoo b09ad5cacb
code cleanup removed unused imports 2021-08-18 10:35:36 +07:00
Jamie Lokier 83b15c83d2
Sync: Add messages about `eth/65` handshake parameters
Signed-off-by: Jamie Lokier <jamie@shareable.org>
2021-07-27 14:12:59 +01:00
Jamie Lokier b28396d10d
Sync: Add packet tracing to `eth/65` in a consistent format
The format is reasonably useful and not too large, when looking at the
behaviour of sync processes.  It doesn't try to show all the details of
packets, just something at a useful level of detail to see what's going on.
The consistent presentation has proven helpful too, e.g. when grepping.

Signed-off-by: Jamie Lokier <jamie@shareable.org>
2021-07-27 14:12:56 +01:00
Jamie Lokier 936a18b4f4
Eth65: Rename and stop exporting `protocolVersion`
This constant shouldn't be used outside `protocol_eth65`.

When we support multiple `eth/NN` versions side by side, or even just have
multiple code files, there's a risk some code would import just one of the
files (e.g. `protocol_eth65`), use `protocolVersion`, and incorrectly act as
though that version is the one active on the node.

In fact that happened, and now it can't happen.  Other code needs to query the
`EtheruemNode` to find what versions are really active.

Signed-off-by: Jamie Lokier <jamie@shareable.org>
2021-07-27 14:12:52 +01:00
Jamie Lokier 889a796b72
Sync: Fix `NewBlockAnnounce` RLP decoding errors
Turns out `{.rlpInline.}` doesn't do anything.
It's documented but not implemented.

Due to this, whenever a peer sent us a `NewBlock` message, we had an RLP
decoding error processing it, and disconnected the peer thinking it was the
peer's error.

These messages are sent often by good peers, so whenever we connected to a
really good peer, we'd end up disconnecting from it due to this.

Because a block body is a list of transactions, the parse errors looked
suspiciously like EIP-2718/2976/2930/1559 typed transaction RLP errors.
But it was a failure to parse `BlockBody` inline.

Conveniently, the `EthBlock` type defined for another reason is encoded exactly
the way `NewBlockAnnounce` needs to be, so we can reuse that type.

This didn't stand out before updating to `eth/65`, because with old protocols
we tend to only connect to old peers, which may be out of date themselves and
have no new blocks to send.  Also, we didn't really investigate occasional
disconnects before, we assumed they're just part of P2P life.

Signed-off-by: Jamie Lokier <jamie@shareable.org>
2021-07-27 14:12:38 +01:00
Jamie Lokier 3161d395a6
Sync: Support for `eth/65` protocol
This patch adds the `eth/65` protocol, documented at
https://github.com/ethereum/devp2p/blob/master/caps/eth.md.

This is an intentionally simple patch, designed to not break, change or depend
on other functionality much, so that the "_old_ sync" methods can be run
usefully again and observed.  This patch isn't "new sync" (a different set of
sync algorithms), but it is one of the foundations.

For a while now Nimbus Eth1 only supported protocol `eth/63`.  But that's
obsolete, and very few nodes still support it.  This meant Nimbus Eth1 would
make slow progress trying to sync, as most up to date clients rejected it.

The current specification is `eth/66`, and the functionality we really need is
in `eth/64`.

So why `eth/65`?

- `eth/64` is essential because of the `forkId` feature.  But `eth/64` is on
  its way out as well.  Many clients, especially the most up to date Geth
  running the current hard-forks (Berlin/London) don't talk `eth/64` any more.

- `eth/66` is the current specification, but some clients don't talk `eth/66`
  yet.  We'd like to have the best peer connectivity during tests, and
  currently everything that talks `eth/66` also talks `eth/65`.

- Nimbus Eth1 RLPx only talks one version at a time.  (Without changes to the
  RLPx module.  When those go in we'll add `eth/64..eth/66` for greater peer
  reach and testing the `eth/66` behaviour.  For simplicity and decoupling,
  this patch contains just one version, the most useful.)

What are `eth/64` and `eth/65`?

- `eth/64` (EIP-2364) added `forkId` which allows nodes to distinguish between
  Ethereum (ETH) and Ethereum Classic (ETC) blockchains, which share the same
  genesis block.  `forkId` also protects the system when a new hard fork is
  going to be rolled out, by blocking interaction with out of date nodes.  The
  feature is required nowadays.

  We send the right details to allow connection (this has been tested a lot),
  but don't apply the full validation rules of EIP-2124/EIP-2364 in this patch.
  It's to keep this patch simple (in its effects) and because those rules have
  consequences best tested separately.  In practice the other node will reject
  us when we would reject it, so this is ok for testing, as long as it doesn't
  get seriously deployed.

- `eth/65` added more efficient transaction pool methods.

- Then a later version of `eth/65` (without a new number) added typed
  transactions, described in [EIP-2976](https://eips.ethereum.org/EIPS/eip-2976).

Why it's moved to `nimbus-eth1`:

- Mainly because `eth/64` onwards depend on the current state of block
  synchronisation, as well as the blockchain's sequence of hard-fork block
  numbers, both of which are part of `nimbus-eth1` run-time state.  These
  aren't available to pure `nim-eth` code.  Although it would be possible to
  add an API to let `nimbus-eth1` set these numbers, there isn't any point
  because the protocol would still only be useful to `nimbus-eth1`.

Signed-off-by: Jamie Lokier <jamie@shareable.org>
2021-07-27 14:12:35 +01:00