- committee_index is used as an input to compute_subnet_for_attestation but it's not previously defined
- attestation.data.committee_index is incorrect, the field is "index"
* deprecate `BeaconBlocksByRange.step`
The `step` parameter has not seen much implementation in real life
clients which instead opt to request variations on a few epochs at a
time (instead of interleaving single blocks, entire epochs are
interleaved).
At the same time, supporting `step` on the server side brings several
complications: more complex bounds checking logic, more complex loading
of blocks from linear storage (which presumably stores all blocks and
not just certain increments).
This PR suggests that we deprecate the whole idea. Backwards
compatibility is kept by simply responding with a single block when
`step > 0` - this is allowed by the spec and should thus be handled
gracefully by requesting clients already, should there exist any that
use larger step counts.
Removing `step` now allows simplifying the EL-CL protocol for serving
execution data from the EL to avoid double storage.
* Update specs/phase0/p2p-interface.md
Co-authored-by: Danny Ryan <dannyjryan@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Danny Ryan <dannyjryan@gmail.com>
* Ignore subset aggregates
When aggregates are propagated through the network, it is often the case
that a better aggregate has already been seen - in particular, this
happens when an aggregator has not been able to include itself in the
mesh and therefore publishes an aggregate with only its own
attestations.
This new ignore rule allows dropping all aggregates that are
(non-strict) subsets of aggregates that have already been seen on the
network. In particular, it does not mandate dropping aggregates where a
union of previous aggregates would cause it to become a subset).
The logic for allowing this is based on the premise that any aggregate
that has already been seen by a peer will also have been seen by its
neighbours - a subset aggregate (strict or not) brings no new value to
the aggregation algorithm, except in the extreme edge case where you
could combine several such sparse aggregates into a single, more dense
"combined" aggregate and thus use less block space.
Further, as a small benefit, computing the `hash_tree_root` of the full
aggregate is generally not done -however, `hash_tree_root(data)` is
already done for other purposes as this is used as index in the beacon
API.
* add subset ignore rule to sync contributions as well
* typo
When nodes are syncing but have not yet reached the canonical `head`,
they cannot determine whether nodes they are connected to serve a valid
history or are making bogus claims in their `Status` advertisement.
Thus, the best course of action that a client can take is to vote for
its "current" best synced head, regardless of whether it's connected to
peers that claim to have other heads or not.
However, in the p2p spec, we penalize such peers with a `REJECT` - this
should be an `IGNORE` instead because this vote is correct per the spec,
albeit "late" according to the validating clients' view of the chain.
The spec reserves the libp2p error code range `[3, 127]` for future use
but actually defines error code `3` as `ResourceUnavailable`. This patch
updates the reserved range to `[4, 127]`.
Hsiao-Wei Wang
David Theodore
fradamt
Jacek Sieka
Caspar Schwarz-Schilling
Mikhail Kalinin
Alex Stokes
Danny Ryan
Caspar Schwarz-Schilling
Michael Sproul
Aditya Asgaonkar
Nishant Das
Etan Kissling
Aditya Asgaonkar
realbigsean
Ben Edgington