mirror of
https://github.com/logos-messaging/OpChan.git
synced 2026-01-03 05:13:09 +00:00
16 KiB
16 KiB
Waku Forum FURPS Compliance Report
Generated: December 2024
Codebase Analysis Date: Current HEAD
Legend: ✅ Fully Implemented | 🟡 Partially Implemented | ❌ Not Implemented | ❔ Unclear/Ambiguous
Executive Summary
This report provides a comprehensive analysis of the OpChan codebase against the specified FURPS requirements. The application shows strong implementation of core forum functionality, authentication systems, and Waku network integration. Key strengths include a sophisticated relevance scoring system, comprehensive moderation capabilities, and effective key delegation for improved UX. Major gaps exist in anonymous user interactions, user identity features, and some usability enhancements.
Overall Compliance: 72% (26/36 requirements fully implemented)
Functionality Requirements
| # | Requirement | Status | Implementation Evidence | File References |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Users can identify themselves by signing with their Bitcoin key | ✅ | Full Bitcoin wallet integration via ReOwnWalletService with signing capabilities | src/lib/identity/wallets/ReOwnWalletService.ts:169-188 |
| 2 | Only users owning Logos ordinal or an ENS can create a cell | 🟡 | ENS ownership checks implemented, but ordinal verification bypassed in development mode | src/lib/forum/actions.ts:180-187, src/lib/identity/ordinal.ts:13-20 |
| 3 | Any user (authenticated or not) can see the content; basic encryption functionality | ✅ | All content viewing routes accessible without authentication | src/pages/*.tsx, src/components/PostList.tsx |
| 4 | Existing cells can be listed | ✅ | Comprehensive cell listing with sorting and filtering | src/components/CellList.tsx:35-120 |
| 5 | Cell can be created with a name, description, icon; icon size restricted; creator is admin | 🟡 | Form validation for URL exists but no size restriction enforcement | src/components/CreateCellDialog.tsx:64-75 |
| 6 | Post can be created in a cell with title and body; text only | ✅ | Full post creation with text validation | src/lib/forum/actions.ts:24-96 |
| 7 | Comments can be made on posts; text only | ✅ | Complete comment system with threading | src/lib/forum/actions.ts:98-168 |
| 8 | Posts can be upvoted | ✅ | Comprehensive voting system with upvote/downvote tracking | src/lib/forum/actions.ts:233-304 |
| 9 | Users can setup call sign; ordinal used as avatar | ❌ | No nickname/call sign fields in User interface; only truncated addresses displayed | src/types/forum.ts:5-24 |
| 10 | Cell admin can mark posts and comments as moderated | ✅ | Full moderation system with reason tracking | src/lib/forum/actions.ts:310-414 |
| 11 | Cell admin can mark users as moderated | ✅ | User-level moderation with cell-scoped restrictions | src/lib/forum/actions.ts:416-459 |
| 12 | Users can identify themselves by signing with Web3 key | ✅ | Ethereum wallet support with ENS resolution via Wagmi | src/lib/identity/wallets/ReOwnWalletService.ts:222-251 |
| 13 | Posts, comments, cells have relevance index for ordering/hiding | ✅ | Sophisticated RelevanceCalculator with multiple scoring factors | src/lib/forum/relevance.ts:4-340 |
| 14 | Relevance lowered for moderated content/users | ✅ | Moderation penalty of 50% reduction applied | src/lib/forum/relevance.ts:62-63 |
| 15 | Relevance increased for ENS/Ordinal owners | ✅ | 25% bonus for verified owners, 10% for basic verification | src/lib/forum/relevance.ts:16-17 |
| 16 | Relevance increased for verified upvoters | ✅ | Verified upvote bonus of 0.1 per verified vote | src/lib/forum/relevance.ts:47-51 |
| 17 | Relevance increased for verified commenters | ✅ | Verified commenter bonus of 0.05 per verified commenter | src/lib/forum/relevance.ts:53-57 |
| 18 | Anonymous users can upvote, comment, and post | ❌ | All actions require authentication and verification checks | src/lib/forum/actions.ts:34-41, 242-249 |
Functionality Score: 14/18 (78%)
Usability Requirements
| # | Requirement | Status | Implementation Evidence | File References |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Users can see all topics through all cells | ✅ | Feed page aggregates posts from all cells | src/pages/FeedPage.tsx:24-27 |
| 2 | Users can see active members per cell | 🟡 | Post count displayed, but active member calculation not fully implemented | src/components/CellList.tsx:31-33 |
| 3 | Users can bookmark posts/topics (local only) | ❌ | No bookmarking functionality found in interfaces or components | Not found |
| 4 | Users can sort topics by new or top | ✅ | Sorting controls with relevance and time options implemented | src/pages/FeedPage.tsx:97-115, src/lib/forum/sorting.ts |
| 5 | Ordinal picture and custom nickname for user ID | 🟡 | CypherImage generates avatars, but no nickname system | src/components/ui/CypherImage.tsx |
| 6 | Moderated content hidden from users | ✅ | Filtering logic hides moderated posts/comments from non-admins | src/components/PostList.tsx:114-118 |
| 7 | Users don't need to sign every message | ✅ | Key delegation system with configurable duration | src/lib/services/CryptoService.ts:250-274 |
| 8 | Only browser needed (no additional software) | ✅ | Web-based with optional wallet integration | Architecture |
| 9 | Prototype UI for dogfooding | ✅ | Complete React UI with shadcn/ui components | src/components/** |
| 10 | Library with clear API for developers | ❌ | Internal services exist but no packaged library or external API | src/lib/index.ts:8-249 |
| 11 | ENS holders can use ENS for display | ✅ | ENS names resolved and displayed throughout UI | src/lib/identity/wallets/ReOwnWalletService.ts:232-236 |
| 12 | Relevance index used for content ranking | ✅ | Relevance-based sorting implemented as default option | src/pages/FeedPage.tsx:21-27 |
Usability Score: 8/12 (67%)
Reliability Requirements
| Requirement | Status | Implementation Evidence | File References |
|---|---|---|---|
| Data is ephemeral; will disappear after time | ✅ | Waku network inherently ephemeral; no permanent storage attempted | src/lib/waku/core/WakuNodeManager.ts |
| End-to-end reliability for missing messages | 🟡 | Basic health monitoring and reconnection logic, but no comprehensive missing message detection | src/lib/waku/core/WakuNodeManager.ts:25-45 |
Reliability Score: 1.5/2 (75%)
Performance Requirements
No specific requirements defined ✅
Supportability Requirements
| Requirement | Status | Implementation Evidence | File References |
|---|---|---|---|
| Web app; wallets optional | ✅ | Read-only functionality without wallet connection | src/pages/Index.tsx |
| Centralized API for Bitcoin ordinal info | ✅ | OrdinalAPI class queries Logos dashboard API | src/lib/identity/ordinal.ts:3-46 |
| Uses Waku Network | ✅ | Complete Waku integration with LightNode and reliable messaging | src/lib/waku/core/*.ts |
Supportability Score: 3/3 (100%)
Privacy, Anonymity, Deployments
| Requirement | Status | Implementation Evidence | File References |
|---|---|---|---|
| Centralized ordinal API | ✅ | Implemented with Logos dashboard integration | src/lib/identity/ordinal.ts:3-46 |
| Uses Waku Network | ✅ | Decentralized messaging infrastructure implemented | src/lib/waku/** |
Privacy/Anonymity Score: 2/2 (100%)
Key Implementation Strengths
🎯 Sophisticated Relevance System
- Full scoring algorithm with base scores, engagement metrics, verification bonuses
- Time decay function and moderation penalties properly implemented
- Comprehensive test coverage for relevance calculations
- Integration with sorting and UI display systems
🔐 Robust Authentication Architecture
- Multi-wallet support (Bitcoin via ReOwnWalletService, Ethereum via Wagmi)
- Key delegation system reducing wallet interaction friction
- ENS integration with proper resolution and display
- Verification tiers (unverified, basic, owner) properly implemented
🛡️ Complete Moderation System
- Cell-level admin controls for posts, comments, and users
- Reason tracking and timestamp recording
- Visibility filtering based on user roles
- Integration with relevance scoring for penalties
📡 Solid Waku Integration
- Reliable messaging with status callbacks
- Health monitoring and reconnection logic
- Message caching and transformation pipeline
- Multi-channel support for different message types
Critical Implementation Gaps
❌ Anonymous User Support (Requirement #18)
Impact: High - Violates key accessibility requirement
Current: All actions require authentication (isAuthenticated checks)
Files: src/lib/forum/actions.ts:34-41, 107-114, 242-249
Fix Required: Remove authentication requirements for voting, posting, commenting
❌ User Identity System (Requirement #9)
Impact: Medium - Core user experience feature missing
Current: No nickname/call sign fields in User interface
Files: src/types/forum.ts:5-24
Fix Required: Add nickname field and call sign setup UI
❌ Bookmarking System (Requirement #21)
Impact: Medium - Important usability feature
Current: No local storage or bookmark functionality found
Files: None found
Fix Required: Implement local bookmark storage and UI
❌ Developer Library (Requirement #28)
Impact: Low - External integration capability
Current: Internal services only, no packaged library
Files: src/lib/index.ts exists but not exported as library
Fix Required: Create npm package with clear API documentation
Technical Architecture Assessment
Message Flow & State Management ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
- Clean separation between Waku messaging and forum domain logic
- Proper message transformation pipeline with verification
- Effective caching strategy with optimistic updates
Security & Cryptography ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
- Proper message signing with delegation support
- Secure key management with expiration
- Protection against signature replay attacks
Error Handling & UX ⭐⭐⭐⭐
- Comprehensive error messages with user-friendly descriptions
- Loading states and network status indicators
- Toast notifications for user feedback
Code Quality & Organization ⭐⭐⭐⭐
- Well-structured TypeScript with proper type definitions
- Clear separation of concerns across modules
- Good test coverage for critical functions
Priority Recommendations
P0 - Critical (Next Sprint)
- Enable Anonymous Interactions - Remove authentication requirements for basic actions
- Fix Ordinal Verification - Implement real ordinal ownership checks for cell creation
- Add Missing User Identity - Implement nickname/call sign system
P1 - High (Next Month)
- Implement Bookmarking - Add local bookmark functionality
- Enhance Active Member Tracking - Calculate and display real active member counts
- Complete Icon Size Validation - Add proper size restrictions for cell icons
P2 - Medium (Future Releases)
- Create Developer Library - Package services as distributable npm module
- Enhance Reliability - Implement comprehensive missing message detection
- Add Advanced Sorting - Extend sorting options beyond time/relevance
Compliance Summary
| Category | Score | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Functionality | 14/18 (78%) | 🟡 Strong core, missing anonymous access |
| Usability | 8/12 (67%) | 🟡 Good UX foundation, needs identity features |
| Reliability | 1.5/2 (75%) | 🟡 Basic reliability, can be enhanced |
| Performance | N/A | ✅ No requirements specified |
| Supportability | 3/3 (100%) | ✅ Full compliance |
| Privacy/Anonymity | 2/2 (100%) | ✅ Full compliance |
🎯 Overall FURPS Compliance: 72% (26/36 requirements fully implemented)