The void arm discarded the dispatch reply. `value = QVariant(true)` was
unconditional: the JSON was parsed, then thrown away, so a provider answering
{"code":"invalid_args", ...} reached the caller as a successful void call.
Invisible until the providers gained something to refuse with. With the arity
upper bound in place (logos-cpp-sdk #150, logos-rust-sdk #50) the provider DOES
refuse `doVoid("junk")` -- the built module carries the `expected 0 arguments,
got ` literal, checked in the exact store path the failing run consumed -- and
the conformance cell still reported `true`, on both providers and all three
consumers. The twelve cells of the non-void arity cases went green in the same
run; these six did not, because their refusal died here rather than at the
provider.
Which is the same defect one layer down from the one the arity work started
from: an answer the caller cannot distinguish from a real one. There the
provider dropped an argument and answered anyway; here the provider refused
correctly and the glue reported success.
The closed set is the one logos-qt-sdk's consumer detector uses --
dispatch_failed / invalid_args / unknown_method -- matched only on an OBJECT
carrying a string `code`. A void method whose provider legitimately answers an
object is unaffected, and there is no such method: the contract says it returns
nothing. An ordinary reply still answers `true`; this is a branch, not a
replacement, and the test pins both sides.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
logos-plugin-qt
Everything specific to running a Logos module as a Qt 6 plugin, in one repo: the build logic logos-module-builder delegates to, and the runtime that build produces plugins against. Keeping both here is what lets the plugin technology be swapped without touching the module builder or individual modules.
Outputs
| Output | What it is |
|---|---|
lib / rawLib |
The Nix build functions (buildPlugin, generate, buildHeaders, devShellInputs, plus common). rawLib takes its Logos deps as arguments; lib pre-fills them from this flake. |
packages.<sys>.logos-qt-host |
The Qt host runtime a plugin links: LogosAPI, LogosAPIProvider, LogosProviderBase, the legacy QtProviderObject adapter, and core/interface.h. Static library, headers, and a find_package(logos-qt-host) config. |
packages.<sys>.logos-qt-host-generator |
Emits the Qt plugin glue around a cdylib module's C ABI (<name>_cdylib_glue.{h,cpp}) from its LIDL contract. |
logos-qt-host is also the default package.
LogosProviderBase's two pure slots — callMethod() and getMethods() — are
filled by logos-qt-host-generator --backend cdylib, in the emitted
<name>_cdylib_glue.cpp. logos_provider_object.h also still defines the
LOGOS_PROVIDER / LOGOS_METHOD macros, but they are vestigial: they were
scanned by logos-cpp-generator --provider-header to emit a
logos_provider_dispatch.cpp for interface: "provider" modules, and that flag,
that interface value and that file are all gone (the flag is now refused with a
message naming interface: "universal"). Under universal a module's plain
public methods are its API — the contract is derived from the impl header
named by codegen.impl_class / codegen.impl_header, and there is no marker to
write. Nothing this repo builds expands either macro any more; they are kept
only so an older translation unit still compiles.
There is no cmake-module output and no LogosModule.cmake here.
LogosModule.cmake lives in logos-module-builder, and only there. This repo
shipped a second copy until the builder was made to point
LOGOS_MODULE_BUILDER_ROOT at its own copy for every module type: the builder
only overrode that variable when a MODULE carried the file (none does), so
ui_qml plugins configured with this repo's copy while core modules configured
with the builder's, and the two drifted apart in silence. The CMake module reads
the builder's own variables (LOGOS_API_STYLE, LOGOS_MODULE_GO_STATIC_LIBS,
generated_code/), so the builder is where it belongs.
cmake/ went away with that copy and is gone for good. It briefly came back to
hold the four LogosView*.in templates logos_module(REP_FILE ...)
instantiates, which had the mirror-image problem — a byte-identical second copy
of them lived here with nothing comparing the two. Both copies are now one copy,
in logos-view-module, which owns the ui_qml authoring flavour end to end:
the templates, LogosViewModule.cmake, the view glue generator, and the
.rep-file replica-factory fixture that proves the plugin an authoring build
produces still loads and casts. logos-module-builder inputs that repo and hands
the directory to every plugin build as LOGOS_VIEW_TEMPLATE_DIR; this backend
never names it.
Which is the line this repo now holds to: it handles exclusively what makes a
cdylib module loadable by logos-module-loader-qt — the Qt host runtime a
plugin links, the generator that wraps a cdylib's C ABI in that plugin, and the
Nix functions that compile and package the result. View-plugin authoring is
somebody else's repo. (buildPlugin still packages a
<name>_replica_factory library when a module's build emits one — that is
plugin packaging of a build artifact, the same as the _plugin library beside
it, and carries no knowledge of where the templates live.)
lib / rawLib are pure Nix and stay that way: nothing reachable from them
mentions the two C++ derivations, so a consumer that only wants the build
functions never realises a Qt or protocol build to get them.
By-name contracts
Two things cross the host/plugin boundary as a string rather than a symbol,
because a plugin and the host that loads it are separate images: each links its
own copy of LogosAPI, ModuleProxy and TokenManager, at distinct addresses
and with no undefined reference to the other's (Mach-O is TWOLEVEL, PE has no
interposition; only ELF's flat namespace collapses them). A direct C++ call
binds to the calling image's copy. QMetaObject::invokeMethod does not — it
resolves through metaObject() / qt_metacall, which are virtual, and the
vptr was written by the host's constructor.
| Contract | Emitted by | Reached by |
|---|---|---|
aboutToUnload() / unloadFinished() |
qt-host-generator, on the plugin class |
cpp/logos_plugin_unload.cpp |
currentCallerJson() — who is calling this dispatch |
cpp/logos_api.h, on LogosAPI |
cpp/logos_provider_object.cpp, then pushed across the module-impl C ABI by the generated glue |
Nothing in either build ties the two ends together: rename one side and every
module still compiles, links and loads, and the feature is simply never found —
a silent, permanent no-op that looks exactly like a module which legitimately
declined. Both halves of both contracts live in this repo, which is what
makes tests/test-unload-contract.nix and tests/test-caller-contract.nix
possible: they scrape the name out of the emitter and require the consumer to
reach for that exact string, in both directions.
Layout
lib/ the Nix build functions (buildPlugin, generate, buildHeaders)
cpp/ the Qt host runtime library (logos-qt-host)
core/interface.h the legacy Qt plugin interface (PluginInterface)
qt-host-generator/ the cdylib -> Qt-plugin glue emitter
nix/ derivations for the two C++ outputs
tests/ flake checks