(Feature) - #1656 Tx is sent to backend even if not signed (#1672)

* Fix black notification

* Fix executing tx even if the user rejected it

* Fix hidden metamask error code

* Fix proccessTransaction notifications and metamask sign reject handling

src/logic/safe/store/actions/createTransaction.ts

@@ -57,6 +57,7 @@ export interface CreateTransactionArgs {
 type CreateTransactionAction = ThunkAction<Promise<void | string>, AppReduxState, DispatchReturn, AnyAction>
 type ConfirmEventHandler = (safeTxHash: string) => void
 type ErrorEventHandler = () => void
+export const METAMASK_REJECT_CONFIRM_TX_ERROR_CODE = 4001
 
 const createTransaction = (
   {
@@ -210,20 +211,21 @@ const createTransaction = (
       ? `${notificationsQueue.afterExecutionError.message} - ${err.message}`
       : notificationsQueue.afterExecutionError.message
 
-    console.error(`Error creating the TX: `, err)
     dispatch(closeSnackbarAction({ key: beforeExecutionKey }))
 
     if (pendingExecutionKey) {
       dispatch(closeSnackbarAction({ key: pendingExecutionKey }))
     }
 
-    dispatch(enqueueSnackbar(errorMsg))
+    dispatch(enqueueSnackbar({ key: err.code, message: errorMsg, options: { persist: true, variant: 'error' } }))
 
-    const executeDataUsedSignatures = safeInstance.methods
+    if (err.code !== METAMASK_REJECT_CONFIRM_TX_ERROR_CODE) {
-      .execTransaction(to, valueInWei, txData, operation, 0, 0, 0, ZERO_ADDRESS, ZERO_ADDRESS, sigs)
+      const executeDataUsedSignatures = safeInstance.methods
-      .encodeABI()
+        .execTransaction(to, valueInWei, txData, operation, 0, 0, 0, ZERO_ADDRESS, ZERO_ADDRESS, sigs)
-    const errMsg = await getErrorMessage(safeInstance.options.address, 0, executeDataUsedSignatures, from)
+        .encodeABI()
-    console.error(`Error creating the TX - an attempt to get the error message: ${errMsg}`)
+      const errMsg = await getErrorMessage(safeInstance.options.address, 0, executeDataUsedSignatures, from)
+      console.error(`Error creating the TX - an attempt to get the error message: ${errMsg}`)
+    }
   }
 
   return txHash

src/logic/safe/store/actions/processTransaction.ts

@@ -97,7 +97,7 @@ const processTransaction = ({
       const signature = await tryOffchainSigning(tx.safeTxHash, { ...txArgs, safeAddress }, hardwareWallet)
 
       if (signature) {
-        dispatch(closeSnackbarAction(beforeExecutionKey))
+        dispatch(closeSnackbarAction({ key: beforeExecutionKey }))
 
         await saveTxToHistory({ ...txArgs, signature })
         // TODO: while we wait for the tx to be stored in the service and later update the tx info
@@ -130,7 +130,7 @@ const processTransaction = ({
       .send(sendParams)
       .once('transactionHash', async (hash: string) => {
         txHash = hash
-        dispatch(closeSnackbarAction(beforeExecutionKey))
+        dispatch(closeSnackbarAction({ key: beforeExecutionKey }))
 
         pendingExecutionKey = dispatch(enqueueSnackbar(notificationsQueue.pendingExecution))
 
@@ -141,19 +141,19 @@ const processTransaction = ({
           ])
           dispatch(fetchTransactions(safeAddress))
         } catch (e) {
-          dispatch(closeSnackbarAction(pendingExecutionKey))
+          dispatch(closeSnackbarAction({ key: pendingExecutionKey }))
           await storeTx({ transaction: tx, safeAddress, dispatch, state })
           console.error(e)
         }
       })
       .on('error', (error) => {
-        dispatch(closeSnackbarAction(pendingExecutionKey))
+        dispatch(closeSnackbarAction({ key: pendingExecutionKey }))
         storeTx({ transaction: tx, safeAddress, dispatch, state })
         console.error('Processing transaction error: ', error)
       })
       .then(async (receipt) => {
         if (pendingExecutionKey) {
-          dispatch(closeSnackbarAction(pendingExecutionKey))
+          dispatch(closeSnackbarAction({ key: pendingExecutionKey }))
         }
 
         dispatch(
@@ -178,17 +178,16 @@ const processTransaction = ({
     const errorMsg = err.message
       ? `${notificationsQueue.afterExecutionError.message} - ${err.message}`
       : notificationsQueue.afterExecutionError.message
-    console.error(err)
 
-    if (txHash !== undefined) {
+    dispatch(closeSnackbarAction({ key: beforeExecutionKey }))
-      dispatch(closeSnackbarAction(beforeExecutionKey))
 
-      if (pendingExecutionKey) {
+    if (pendingExecutionKey) {
-        dispatch(closeSnackbarAction(pendingExecutionKey))
+      dispatch(closeSnackbarAction({ key: pendingExecutionKey }))
-      }
+    }
 
-      dispatch(enqueueSnackbar(errorMsg))
+    dispatch(enqueueSnackbar({ key: err.code, message: errorMsg, options: { persist: true, variant: 'error' } }))
 
+    if (txHash) {
       const executeData = safeInstance.methods.approveHash(txHash).encodeABI()
       const errMsg = await getErrorMessage(safeInstance.options.address, 0, executeData, from)
       console.error(`Error executing the TX: ${errMsg}`)

src/logic/safe/transactions/offchainSigner/index.ts

@@ -1,5 +1,6 @@
 import { getEIP712Signer } from './EIP712Signer'
 import { ethSigner } from './ethSigner'
+import { METAMASK_REJECT_CONFIRM_TX_ERROR_CODE } from 'src/logic/safe/store/actions/createTransaction'
 
 // 1. we try to sign via EIP-712 if user's wallet supports it
 // 2. If not, try to use eth_sign (Safe version has to be >1.1.1)
@@ -29,9 +30,8 @@ export const tryOffchainSigning = async (safeTxHash: string, txArgs, isHW: boole
       break
     } catch (err) {
       console.error(err)
-      // Metamask sign request error code
+      if (err.code === METAMASK_REJECT_CONFIRM_TX_ERROR_CODE) {
-      if (err.code === 4001) {
+        throw err
-        throw new Error('User denied sign request')
       }
     }
   }