# beacon_chain # Copyright (c) 2018-2024 Status Research & Development GmbH # Licensed and distributed under either of # * MIT license (license terms in the root directory or at https://opensource.org/licenses/MIT). # * Apache v2 license (license terms in the root directory or at https://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0). # at your option. This file may not be copied, modified, or distributed except according to those terms. {.push raises: [].} import std/tables, stew/results, chronicles, chronos, metrics, taskpools, ../spec/[helpers, forks], ../spec/datatypes/[altair, phase0, deneb, eip7594], ../consensus_object_pools/[ blob_quarantine, block_clearance, block_quarantine, blockchain_dag, attestation_pool, light_client_pool, sync_committee_msg_pool, validator_change_pool], ../validators/validator_pool, ../beacon_clock, "."/[gossip_validation, block_processor, batch_validation], ../nimbus_binary_common export results, taskpools, block_clearance, blockchain_dag, attestation_pool, light_client_pool, sync_committee_msg_pool, validator_change_pool, validator_pool, beacon_clock, gossip_validation, block_processor, batch_validation, block_quarantine logScope: topics = "gossip_eth2" # Metrics for tracking attestation and beacon block loss declareCounter beacon_attestations_received, "Number of valid unaggregated attestations processed by this node" declareCounter beacon_attestations_dropped, "Number of invalid unaggregated attestations dropped by this node", labels = ["reason"] declareCounter beacon_aggregates_received, "Number of valid aggregated attestations processed by this node" declareCounter beacon_aggregates_dropped, "Number of invalid aggregated attestations dropped by this node", labels = ["reason"] declareCounter beacon_blocks_received, "Number of valid blocks processed by this node" declareCounter beacon_blocks_dropped, "Number of invalid blocks dropped by this node", labels = ["reason"] declareCounter blob_sidecars_received, "Number of valid blobs processed by this node" declareCounter blob_sidecars_dropped, "Number of invalid blobs dropped by this node", labels = ["reason"] declareCounter data_column_sidecars_received, "Number of valid data column sidecars processed by this node" declareCounter data_column_sidecars_dropped, "Number of invalid data column sidecars dropped by this node", labels = ["reason"] declareCounter beacon_attester_slashings_received, "Number of valid attester slashings processed by this node" declareCounter beacon_attester_slashings_dropped, "Number of invalid attester slashings dropped by this node", labels = ["reason"] declareCounter bls_to_execution_change_received, "Number of valid BLS to execution changes processed by this node" declareCounter bls_to_execution_change_dropped, "Number of invalid BLS to execution changes dropped by this node", labels = ["reason"] declareCounter beacon_proposer_slashings_received, "Number of valid proposer slashings processed by this node" declareCounter beacon_proposer_slashings_dropped, "Number of invalid proposer slashings dropped by this node", labels = ["reason"] declareCounter beacon_voluntary_exits_received, "Number of valid voluntary exits processed by this node" declareCounter beacon_voluntary_exits_dropped, "Number of invalid voluntary exits dropped by this node", labels = ["reason"] declareCounter beacon_sync_committee_messages_received, "Number of valid sync committee messages processed by this node" declareCounter beacon_sync_committee_messages_dropped, "Number of invalid sync committee messages dropped by this node", labels = ["reason"] declareCounter beacon_sync_committee_contributions_received, "Number of valid sync committee contributions processed by this node" declareCounter beacon_sync_committee_contributions_dropped, "Number of invalid sync committee contributions dropped by this node", labels = ["reason"] declareCounter beacon_light_client_finality_update_received, "Number of valid light client finality update processed by this node" declareCounter beacon_light_client_finality_update_dropped, "Number of invalid light client finality update dropped by this node", labels = ["reason"] declareCounter beacon_light_client_optimistic_update_received, "Number of valid light client optimistic update processed by this node" declareCounter beacon_light_client_optimistic_update_dropped, "Number of invalid light client optimistic update dropped by this node", labels = ["reason"] const delayBuckets = [2.0, 4.0, 6.0, 8.0, 10.0, 12.0, 14.0, Inf] declareHistogram beacon_attestation_delay, "Time(s) between slot start and attestation reception", buckets = delayBuckets declareHistogram beacon_aggregate_delay, "Time(s) between slot start and aggregate reception", buckets = delayBuckets declareHistogram beacon_block_delay, "Time(s) between slot start and beacon block reception", buckets = delayBuckets declareHistogram blob_sidecar_delay, "Time(s) between slot start and blob sidecar reception", buckets = delayBuckets declareHistogram data_column_sidecar_delay, "Time(s) between slot start and data column sidecar reception", buckets = delayBuckets type DoppelgangerProtection = object broadcastStartEpoch*: Epoch ##\ ## Set anew, each time gossip is re-enabled after syncing completes, so ## might reset multiple times per instance. This allows some safe level ## of gossip interleaving between nodes so long as they don't gossip at ## the same time. Eth2Processor* = object ## The Eth2Processor is the entry point for untrusted message processing - ## when we receive messages from various sources, we pass them to the ## processor for validation and routing - the messages are generally ## validated, and if valid, passed on to the various pools, monitors and ## managers to update the state of the application. ## ## Block processing is special in that part of it is done in the ## `BlockProcessor` instead, via a special block processing queue. ## ## Each validating function generally will do a sanity check on the message ## whose purpose is to quickly filter out spam, then will (usually) delegate ## full validation to the proper manager - finally, metrics and monitoring ## are updated. doppelgangerDetectionEnabled*: bool # Local sources of truth for validation # ---------------------------------------------------------------- dag*: ChainDAGRef attestationPool*: ref AttestationPool validatorPool: ref ValidatorPool syncCommitteeMsgPool: ref SyncCommitteeMsgPool lightClientPool: ref LightClientPool doppelgangerDetection*: DoppelgangerProtection # Gossip validated -> enqueue for further verification # ---------------------------------------------------------------- blockProcessor*: ref BlockProcessor # Validator monitoring validatorMonitor: ref ValidatorMonitor # Validated with no further verification required # ---------------------------------------------------------------- validatorChangePool: ref ValidatorChangePool # Almost validated, pending cryptographic signature check # ---------------------------------------------------------------- batchCrypto*: ref BatchCrypto # Missing information # ---------------------------------------------------------------- quarantine*: ref Quarantine blobQuarantine*: ref BlobQuarantine # Application-provided current time provider (to facilitate testing) getCurrentBeaconTime*: GetBeaconTimeFn ValidationRes* = Result[void, ValidationError] func toValidationResult*(res: ValidationRes): ValidationResult = if res.isOk(): ValidationResult.Accept else: res.error()[0] # Initialization # ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ proc new*(T: type Eth2Processor, doppelgangerDetectionEnabled: bool, blockProcessor: ref BlockProcessor, validatorMonitor: ref ValidatorMonitor, dag: ChainDAGRef, attestationPool: ref AttestationPool, validatorChangePool: ref ValidatorChangePool, validatorPool: ref ValidatorPool, syncCommitteeMsgPool: ref SyncCommitteeMsgPool, lightClientPool: ref LightClientPool, quarantine: ref Quarantine, blobQuarantine: ref BlobQuarantine, rng: ref HmacDrbgContext, getBeaconTime: GetBeaconTimeFn, taskpool: TaskPoolPtr ): ref Eth2Processor = (ref Eth2Processor)( doppelgangerDetectionEnabled: doppelgangerDetectionEnabled, doppelgangerDetection: DoppelgangerProtection( broadcastStartEpoch: FAR_FUTURE_EPOCH), blockProcessor: blockProcessor, validatorMonitor: validatorMonitor, dag: dag, attestationPool: attestationPool, validatorChangePool: validatorChangePool, validatorPool: validatorPool, syncCommitteeMsgPool: syncCommitteeMsgPool, lightClientPool: lightClientPool, quarantine: quarantine, blobQuarantine: blobQuarantine, getCurrentBeaconTime: getBeaconTime, batchCrypto: BatchCrypto.new( rng = rng, # Only run eager attestation signature verification if we're not # processing blocks in order to give priority to block processing eager = proc(): bool = not blockProcessor[].hasBlocks(), genesis_validators_root = dag.genesis_validators_root, taskpool).expect( "working batcher") ) # Each validator logs, validates then passes valid data to its destination # further down the line - in particular, validation should generally not have # any side effects until the message is fully validated, or invalid messages # could be used to push out valid messages. proc processSignedBeaconBlock*( self: var Eth2Processor, src: MsgSource, signedBlock: ForkySignedBeaconBlock, maybeFinalized: bool = false): ValidationRes = let wallTime = self.getCurrentBeaconTime() (afterGenesis, wallSlot) = wallTime.toSlot() logScope: blockRoot = shortLog(signedBlock.root) blck = shortLog(signedBlock.message) signature = shortLog(signedBlock.signature) wallSlot if not afterGenesis: notice "Block before genesis" return errIgnore("Block before genesis") # Potential under/overflows are fine; would just create odd metrics and logs let delay = wallTime - signedBlock.message.slot.start_beacon_time # Start of block processing - in reality, we have already gone through SSZ # decoding at this stage, which may be significant debug "Block received", delay let v = self.dag.validateBeaconBlock(self.quarantine, signedBlock, wallTime, {}) if v.isOk(): # Block passed validation - enqueue it for processing. The block processing # queue is effectively unbounded as we use a freestanding task to enqueue # the block - this is done so that when blocks arrive concurrently with # sync, we don't lose the gossip blocks, but also don't block the gossip # propagation of seemingly good blocks trace "Block validated" let blobs = when typeof(signedBlock).kind >= ConsensusFork.Deneb: if self.blobQuarantine[].hasBlobs(signedBlock): Opt.some(self.blobQuarantine[].popBlobs(signedBlock.root, signedBlock)) else: discard self.quarantine[].addBlobless(self.dag.finalizedHead.slot, signedBlock) return v else: Opt.none(BlobSidecars) self.blockProcessor[].enqueueBlock( src, ForkedSignedBeaconBlock.init(signedBlock), blobs, maybeFinalized = maybeFinalized, validationDur = nanoseconds( (self.getCurrentBeaconTime() - wallTime).nanoseconds)) # Validator monitor registration for blocks is done by the processor beacon_blocks_received.inc() beacon_block_delay.observe(delay.toFloatSeconds()) else: debug "Dropping block", error = v.error() self.blockProcessor[].dumpInvalidBlock(signedBlock) beacon_blocks_dropped.inc(1, [$v.error[0]]) v proc processBlobSidecar*( self: var Eth2Processor, src: MsgSource, blobSidecar: deneb.BlobSidecar, subnet_id: BlobId): ValidationRes = template block_header: untyped = blobSidecar.signed_block_header.message let wallTime = self.getCurrentBeaconTime() (_, wallSlot) = wallTime.toSlot() logScope: blob = shortLog(blobSidecar) wallSlot # Potential under/overflows are fine; would just create odd metrics and logs let delay = wallTime - block_header.slot.start_beacon_time debug "Blob received", delay let v = self.dag.validateBlobSidecar(self.quarantine, self.blobQuarantine, blobSidecar, wallTime, subnet_id) if v.isErr(): debug "Dropping blob", error = v.error() blob_sidecars_dropped.inc(1, [$v.error[0]]) return v debug "Blob validated, putting in blob quarantine" self.blobQuarantine[].put(newClone(blobSidecar)) let block_root = hash_tree_root(block_header) if (let o = self.quarantine[].popBlobless(block_root); o.isSome): let blobless = o.unsafeGet() withBlck(blobless): when consensusFork >= ConsensusFork.Deneb: if self.blobQuarantine[].hasBlobs(forkyBlck): self.blockProcessor[].enqueueBlock( MsgSource.gossip, blobless, Opt.some(self.blobQuarantine[].popBlobs(block_root, forkyBlck))) else: discard self.quarantine[].addBlobless( self.dag.finalizedHead.slot, forkyBlck) else: raiseAssert "Could not have been added as blobless" blob_sidecars_received.inc() blob_sidecar_delay.observe(delay.toFloatSeconds()) v proc processDataColumnSidecar*( self: var Eth2Processor, src: MsgSource, dataColumnSidecar: DataColumnSidecar, subnet_id: uint64): ValidationRes = template block_header: untyped = dataColumnSidecar.signed_block_header.message let wallTime = self.getCurrentBeaconTime() (_, wallSlot) = wallTime.toSlot() logScope: dcs = shortLog(dataColumnSidecar) wallSlot # Potential under/overflows are fine; would just create odd metrics and logs let delay = wallTime - block_header.slot.start_beacon_time debug "Data column received", delay let v = self.dag.validateDataColumnSidecar(self.quarantine, self.blobQuarantine, dataColumnSidecar, wallTime, subnet_id) if v.isErr(): debug "Dropping data column", error = v.error() blob_sidecars_dropped.inc(1, [$v.error[0]]) return v debug "Data column validated" # TODO do something with it! data_column_sidecars_received.inc() data_column_sidecar_delay.observe(delay.toFloatSeconds()) v proc setupDoppelgangerDetection*(self: var Eth2Processor, slot: Slot) = # When another client's already running, this is very likely to detect # potential duplicate validators, which can trigger slashing. # # Every missed attestation costs approximately 3*get_base_reward(), which # can be up to around 10,000 Wei. Thus, skipping attestations isn't cheap # and one should gauge the likelihood of this simultaneous launch to tune # the epoch delay to one's perceived risk. # Round up to ensure that we cover the entire epoch - used by rest api also self.doppelgangerDetection.broadcastStartEpoch = (slot + SLOTS_PER_EPOCH - 1).epoch if self.doppelgangerDetectionEnabled: notice "Setting up doppelganger detection", epoch = slot.epoch, broadcast_epoch = self.doppelgangerDetection.broadcastStartEpoch proc clearDoppelgangerProtection*(self: var Eth2Processor) = self.doppelgangerDetection.broadcastStartEpoch = FAR_FUTURE_EPOCH proc checkForPotentialDoppelganger( self: var Eth2Processor, attestation: phase0.Attestation | electra.Attestation, attesterIndices: openArray[ValidatorIndex]) = # Only check for attestations after node launch. There might be one slot of # overlap in quick intra-slot restarts so trade off a few true negatives in # the service of avoiding more likely false positives. if not self.doppelgangerDetectionEnabled: return for validatorIndex in attesterIndices: let pubkey = self.dag.validatorKey(validatorIndex).get().toPubKey() if self.validatorPool[].triggersDoppelganger( pubkey, attestation.data.slot.epoch): warn "Doppelganger attestation", validator = shortLog(pubkey), validator_index = validatorIndex, attestation = shortLog(attestation) quitDoppelganger() proc processAttestation*( self: ref Eth2Processor, src: MsgSource, attestation: phase0.Attestation | electra.Attestation, subnet_id: SubnetId, checkSignature: bool = true): Future[ValidationRes] {.async: (raises: [CancelledError]).} = var wallTime = self.getCurrentBeaconTime() let (afterGenesis, wallSlot) = wallTime.toSlot() logScope: attestation = shortLog(attestation) subnet_id wallSlot if not afterGenesis: notice "Attestation before genesis" return errIgnore("Attestation before genesis") # Potential under/overflows are fine; would just create odd metrics and logs let delay = wallTime - attestation.data.slot.attestation_deadline debug "Attestation received", delay # Now proceed to validation let v = await self.attestationPool.validateAttestation( self.batchCrypto, attestation, wallTime, subnet_id, checkSignature) return if v.isOk(): # Due to async validation the wallTime here might have changed wallTime = self.getCurrentBeaconTime() let (attester_index, sig) = v.get() self[].checkForPotentialDoppelganger(attestation, [attester_index]) trace "Attestation validated" self.attestationPool[].addAttestation( attestation, [attester_index], sig, wallTime) self.validatorMonitor[].registerAttestation( src, wallTime, attestation, attester_index) beacon_attestations_received.inc() beacon_attestation_delay.observe(delay.toFloatSeconds()) ok() else: debug "Dropping attestation", reason = $v.error beacon_attestations_dropped.inc(1, [$v.error[0]]) err(v.error()) proc processSignedAggregateAndProof*( self: ref Eth2Processor, src: MsgSource, signedAggregateAndProof: phase0.SignedAggregateAndProof | electra.SignedAggregateAndProof, checkSignature = true, checkCover = true): Future[ValidationRes] {.async: (raises: [CancelledError]).} = var wallTime = self.getCurrentBeaconTime() let (afterGenesis, wallSlot) = wallTime.toSlot() logScope: aggregate = shortLog(signedAggregateAndProof.message.aggregate) aggregator_index = signedAggregateAndProof.message.aggregator_index selection_proof = shortLog(signedAggregateAndProof.message.selection_proof) signature = shortLog(signedAggregateAndProof.signature) wallSlot if not afterGenesis: notice "Aggregate before genesis" return errIgnore("Aggregate before genesis") # Potential under/overflows are fine; would just create odd logs let slot = signedAggregateAndProof.message.aggregate.data.slot delay = wallTime - slot.aggregate_deadline debug "Aggregate received", delay let v = await self.attestationPool.validateAggregate( self.batchCrypto, signedAggregateAndProof, wallTime, checkSignature = checkSignature, checkCover = checkCover) return if v.isOk(): # Due to async validation the wallTime here might have changed wallTime = self.getCurrentBeaconTime() let (attesting_indices, sig) = v.get() self[].checkForPotentialDoppelganger( signedAggregateAndProof.message.aggregate, attesting_indices) trace "Aggregate validated" self.attestationPool[].addAttestation( signedAggregateAndProof.message.aggregate, attesting_indices, sig, wallTime) self.validatorMonitor[].registerAggregate( src, wallTime, signedAggregateAndProof.message, attesting_indices) beacon_aggregates_received.inc() beacon_aggregate_delay.observe(delay.toFloatSeconds()) ok() else: debug "Dropping aggregate", reason = $v.error beacon_aggregates_dropped.inc(1, [$v.error[0]]) err(v.error()) proc processBlsToExecutionChange*( self: ref Eth2Processor, src: MsgSource, blsToExecutionChange: SignedBLSToExecutionChange): Future[ValidationRes] {.async: (raises: [CancelledError]).} = logScope: blsToExecutionChange = shortLog(blsToExecutionChange) debug "BLS to execution change received" let v = await self.validatorChangePool[].validateBlsToExecutionChange( self.batchCrypto, blsToExecutionChange, self.getCurrentBeaconTime().slotOrZero.epoch) if v.isOk(): trace "BLS to execution change validated" # Prioritize API-provided messages self.validatorChangePool[].addMessage( blsToExecutionChange, src == MsgSource.api) else: debug "Dropping BLS to execution change", reason = $v.error beacon_attester_slashings_dropped.inc(1, [$v.error[0]]) return v proc processAttesterSlashing*( self: var Eth2Processor, src: MsgSource, attesterSlashing: phase0.AttesterSlashing): ValidationRes = logScope: attesterSlashing = shortLog(attesterSlashing) debug "Attester slashing received" let v = self.validatorChangePool[].validateAttesterSlashing(attesterSlashing) if v.isOk(): trace "Attester slashing validated" self.validatorChangePool[].addMessage(attesterSlashing) self.validatorMonitor[].registerAttesterSlashing(src, attesterSlashing) beacon_attester_slashings_received.inc() else: debug "Dropping attester slashing", reason = $v.error beacon_attester_slashings_dropped.inc(1, [$v.error[0]]) v proc processProposerSlashing*( self: var Eth2Processor, src: MsgSource, proposerSlashing: ProposerSlashing): Result[void, ValidationError] = logScope: proposerSlashing = shortLog(proposerSlashing) debug "Proposer slashing received" let v = self.validatorChangePool[].validateProposerSlashing(proposerSlashing) if v.isOk(): trace "Proposer slashing validated" self.validatorChangePool[].addMessage(proposerSlashing) self.validatorMonitor[].registerProposerSlashing(src, proposerSlashing) beacon_proposer_slashings_received.inc() else: debug "Dropping proposer slashing", reason = $v.error beacon_proposer_slashings_dropped.inc(1, [$v.error[0]]) v proc processSignedVoluntaryExit*( self: var Eth2Processor, src: MsgSource, signedVoluntaryExit: SignedVoluntaryExit): Result[void, ValidationError] = logScope: signedVoluntaryExit = shortLog(signedVoluntaryExit) debug "Voluntary exit received" let v = self.validatorChangePool[].validateVoluntaryExit(signedVoluntaryExit) if v.isOk(): trace "Voluntary exit validated" self.validatorChangePool[].addMessage(signedVoluntaryExit) self.validatorMonitor[].registerVoluntaryExit( src, signedVoluntaryExit.message) beacon_voluntary_exits_received.inc() else: debug "Dropping voluntary exit", reason = $v.error beacon_voluntary_exits_dropped.inc(1, [$v.error[0]]) v proc processSyncCommitteeMessage*( self: ref Eth2Processor, src: MsgSource, syncCommitteeMsg: SyncCommitteeMessage, subcommitteeIdx: SyncSubcommitteeIndex, checkSignature: bool = true): Future[Result[void, ValidationError]] {.async: (raises: [CancelledError]).} = let wallTime = self.getCurrentBeaconTime() wallSlot = wallTime.slotOrZero() logScope: syncCommitteeMsg = shortLog(syncCommitteeMsg) subcommitteeIdx wallSlot # Potential under/overflows are fine; would just create odd metrics and logs let delay = wallTime - syncCommitteeMsg.slot.sync_committee_message_deadline debug "Sync committee message received", delay # Now proceed to validation let v = await validateSyncCommitteeMessage( self.dag, self.quarantine, self.batchCrypto, self.syncCommitteeMsgPool, syncCommitteeMsg, subcommitteeIdx, wallTime, checkSignature) return if v.isOk(): trace "Sync committee message validated" let (bid, cookedSig, positions) = v.get() self.syncCommitteeMsgPool[].addSyncCommitteeMessage( syncCommitteeMsg.slot, bid, syncCommitteeMsg.validator_index, cookedSig, subcommitteeIdx, positions) self.validatorMonitor[].registerSyncCommitteeMessage( src, wallTime, syncCommitteeMsg) beacon_sync_committee_messages_received.inc() ok() else: debug "Dropping sync committee message", reason = $v.error beacon_sync_committee_messages_dropped.inc(1, [$v.error[0]]) err(v.error()) proc processSignedContributionAndProof*( self: ref Eth2Processor, src: MsgSource, contributionAndProof: SignedContributionAndProof, checkSignature: bool = true): Future[Result[void, ValidationError]] {.async: (raises: [CancelledError]).} = let wallTime = self.getCurrentBeaconTime() wallSlot = wallTime.slotOrZero() logScope: contribution = shortLog(contributionAndProof.message.contribution) signature = shortLog(contributionAndProof.signature) aggregator_index = contributionAndProof.message.aggregator_index selection_proof = contributionAndProof.message.selection_proof wallSlot # Potential under/overflows are fine; would just create odd metrics and logs let slot = contributionAndProof.message.contribution.slot delay = wallTime - slot.sync_contribution_deadline debug "Contribution received", delay # Now proceed to validation let v = await validateContribution( self.dag, self.quarantine, self.batchCrypto, self.syncCommitteeMsgPool, contributionAndProof, wallTime, checkSignature) return if v.isOk(): trace "Contribution validated" let (bid, sig, participants) = v.get self.syncCommitteeMsgPool[].addContribution( contributionAndProof, bid, sig) self.validatorMonitor[].registerSyncContribution( src, wallTime, contributionAndProof.message, participants) beacon_sync_committee_contributions_received.inc() ok() else: debug "Dropping contribution", reason = $v.error beacon_sync_committee_contributions_dropped.inc(1, [$v.error[0]]) err(v.error()) # https://github.com/ethereum/consensus-specs/blob/v1.4.0-beta.5/specs/altair/light-client/sync-protocol.md#process_light_client_finality_update proc processLightClientFinalityUpdate*( self: var Eth2Processor, src: MsgSource, finality_update: ForkedLightClientFinalityUpdate ): Result[void, ValidationError] = let wallTime = self.getCurrentBeaconTime() v = validateLightClientFinalityUpdate( self.lightClientPool[], self.dag, finality_update, wallTime) if v.isOk(): beacon_light_client_finality_update_received.inc() else: beacon_light_client_finality_update_dropped.inc(1, [$v.error[0]]) v # https://github.com/ethereum/consensus-specs/blob/v1.4.0-beta.5/specs/altair/light-client/sync-protocol.md#process_light_client_optimistic_update proc processLightClientOptimisticUpdate*( self: var Eth2Processor, src: MsgSource, optimistic_update: ForkedLightClientOptimisticUpdate ): Result[void, ValidationError] = let wallTime = self.getCurrentBeaconTime() v = validateLightClientOptimisticUpdate( self.lightClientPool[], self.dag, optimistic_update, wallTime) if v.isOk(): beacon_light_client_optimistic_update_received.inc() else: beacon_light_client_optimistic_update_dropped.inc(1, [$v.error[0]]) v