Commit Graph

3622 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
tersec 230626306a
use fcU V3 in Deneb/Cancun (#5293) 2023-08-15 23:00:35 +00:00
tersec c3584a9ea7
fix regression in remote signing REST schema (#5294) 2023-08-15 22:39:12 +00:00
Eugene Kabanov 025b0e3f04
VC: Refactor sync committee duties and selection proofs calculation. (#5184)
* Initial commit.

* Fix issues in fill*() procedures.

* Enable sync committee processing.

* Address review comments.

* Address remaining review comments.

* Add sync committee selection proof pruning mechanism.

* Fix recursion issue.
2023-08-15 19:00:27 +02:00
Eugene Kabanov 255131d331
Bump chronos. (#5281)
Add current/last connection query to the connection information.
2023-08-15 13:14:34 +02:00
tersec af37a96dbd
don't send fcUs every block if in lc-opt regime and block putatively finalized (#5248) 2023-08-15 09:27:56 +00:00
Jacek Sieka f77548310f
avoid quadratic attestation queue iteration (#5288)
every attestation is processed with a new wall time so we end up
iterating over all attestations for every attestation we queue - this is
4% of cpu time on a subscribe-all-subnets node

* remove redundant zero checks - block root must be an existing block
and therefore cannot be zero
* simplify "hasn't-voted" check to root only (isZeroMemory is dubiously
implemented for objects)
2023-08-14 16:48:30 +03:00
tersec d171303133
update some consensus spec URLs to v1.4.0-beta.1 (#5287) 2023-08-12 10:38:06 +00:00
tersec 6cd8f3ba55
Update constants/presets for consistency with consensus-specs v1.4.0 (#5284) 2023-08-12 03:10:12 +00:00
henridf 9efd26c2e9
Add support for POST /eth/v2/beacon/blocks (#5214)
* Add support for POST /eth/v2/beacon/blocks

* More descriptive errors

* Address review feedback

* Return 500 (not 400) for a missing implementation case
2023-08-12 03:08:54 +00:00
henridf 9ceed40090
Prune blobs (#5283)
* Prune blobs

* Address review feedback
2023-08-11 00:15:34 +00:00
Jacek Sieka 3c9fc49411
reduce ncli/research imports (#5275)
* reduce ncli/research imports

avoids ssl, most of chronos etc, speeds up compiles

* copyright
2023-08-10 14:52:49 +02:00
Etan Kissling 973e9e9a98
speed up LC signature verification (#5268)
We know the aggregate publickey of a fully participating sync committee.
Because participation is typically very high (>95%), it is faster to
start from that aggregate publickey and subtract the individual keys of
non-participants, than summing up all the participating pubkeys.
2023-08-09 08:50:07 +02:00
tersec 85e1976ac3
automated consensus spec URL updating to v1.4.0-beta.1 (#5280) 2023-08-09 03:58:47 +00:00
tersec 8c3d1cd3aa
ensure `ValidatorPubKey` int-compatibly aligned to fix UB (#5277)
* ensure ValidatorPubKey int-compatibly aligned

* use sizeof(Hash) explicitly
2023-08-08 19:01:32 +00:00
tersec f8520c8b1c
use v1.4.0 stability subnets by default (#5276) 2023-08-08 19:01:04 +00:00
tersec 18061f7991
Remove most remaining portions of Bellatrix Builder API (#5272) 2023-08-08 00:05:17 +00:00
Etan Kissling 6a2bac5cee
need even more log lines for debugging keymanager (#5260)
Keymanager test logs are still cut off, further increase log lines.
2023-08-07 18:02:08 +02:00
tersec b9920a3a59
don't overwrite immutable parts of already-present validators (#5264) 2023-08-07 14:52:42 +00:00
Etan Kissling d7afa1c78a
add helpers for processing EL block header to `libnimbus_lc.a` (#5199)
To obtain the correct `transactions_root` and `withdrawals_root`,
it is necessary to process execution block header. Light client updates
don't contain the correct MPT roots.
2023-08-07 14:23:44 +02:00
tersec 2c424cac87
Merkle is someone's name (#5265) 2023-08-07 10:06:47 +00:00
tersec d97027fb43
remove less-than-useful warning (#5245)
* remove less-than-useful warning

* remove redundant check for node.config.payloadBuilderEnable
2023-08-06 15:12:32 +00:00
tersec 2ae2d0a042
remove Bellatrix Builder API (Signed)BuilderBid (#5262)
* remove Bellatrix Builder API (Signed)BuilderBid

* stub out BlindedBeaconBlock
2023-08-06 09:20:43 +00:00
Etan Kissling 5b70a686e3
further adjust `test_keymanager_api` logs (#5259)
It is still unclear how `test_keymanager_api` sometimes fails in CI;
further adjust logging parameters.
2023-08-05 13:12:44 +00:00
Etan Kissling ee00fb3d80
replace copy with symlink (#5252)
One of the test files is accidentally a copy instead of a symlink.
2023-08-05 11:06:55 +00:00
Etan Kissling e9940115e4
switch from `create`/`dealloc` to `new+GC_ref`/`GC_unref` (#5238)
Using `create` with objects containing managed objects is broken:
https://github.com/nim-lang/Nim/issues/22341

Switch to a safer pattern based on `new+GC_ref`/`GC_unref` instead.
2023-08-05 09:26:27 +02:00
tersec 1f5dd83fbd
unplumbing Bellatrix builder API support (#5203) 2023-08-05 05:13:08 +00:00
tersec d542410a17
remove more Bellatrix-only Builder API support infrastructure (#5251) 2023-08-05 00:11:51 +00:00
tersec 001fbd0970
Revert "Revert "correctly align genesis size (#5244)" (#5253)" (#5254)
This reverts commit 26dcee111b.
2023-08-04 20:49:12 +00:00
tersec 26dcee111b
Revert "correctly align genesis size (#5244)" (#5253)
This reverts commit 706ce01bb1.
2023-08-04 20:11:20 +00:00
Jacek Sieka 706ce01bb1
correctly align genesis size (#5244) 2023-08-04 18:08:15 +03:00
tersec 1c55ef7345
note summary data about invalid baked-in states (#5247) 2023-08-04 07:36:42 +02:00
Etan Kissling 50dfd846f0
fix inconsistent capitalization (#5240)
Two cases of inconsistent capitalization, fix them.
2023-08-03 18:53:32 +02:00
Jacek Sieka b8a32419b8
async batch verification (+40% sig verification throughput) (#5176)
* async batch verification

When batch verification is done, the main thread is blocked reducing
concurrency.

With this PR, the new thread signalling primitive in chronos is used to
offload the full batch verification process to a separate thread
allowing the main threads to continue async operations while the other
threads verify signatures.

Similar to previous behavior, the number of ongoing batch verifications
is capped to prevent runaway resource usage.

In addition to the asynchronous processing, 3 addition changes help
drive throughput:

* A loop is used for batch accumulation: this prevents a stampede of
small batches in eager mode where both the eager and the scheduled batch
runner would pick batches off the queue, prematurely picking "fresh"
batches off the queue
* An additional small wait is introduced for small batches - this helps
create slightly larger batches which make better used of the increased
concurrency
* Up to 2 batches are scheduled to the threadpool during high pressure,
reducing startup latency for the threads

Together, these changes increase attestation verification throughput
under load up to 30%.

* fixup

* Update submodules

* fix blst build issues (and a PIC warning)

* bump

---------

Co-authored-by: Zahary Karadjov <zahary@gmail.com>
2023-08-03 11:36:45 +03:00
Jacek Sieka 5bc48acc36
reduce memory allocations during state transition (#5235)
This PR removes a few hundred thousand temporary seq allocations during
state transition - in particular, the flag seq was allocated per
validator while committees are computed per attestation.
2023-08-03 01:03:40 +02:00
henridf 28194468c9
Rename "data gas" to "blob gas" (#5216)
* Rename data gas to blob gas

* Update vendor/nim-eth and vendor/nim-web3
2023-08-02 22:07:57 +00:00
henridf 1da82a5dcd
Remove async blob queue from Request Manager (#5198)
* Remove async blob queue from Request Manager

* Review feedback

* Review feedback
2023-08-01 22:39:14 +02:00
tersec e9a17fb99f
remove workaround for long-since-fixed Nim bug (#5219) 2023-07-31 22:20:09 +00:00
tersec 909a7c2d07
use v1.4.0-beta.1 consensus spec tests (#5230) 2023-07-31 21:51:06 +00:00
Etan Kissling f8ba2e3882
generalize `ShufflingRef` acceleration logic (#5197) (#5204)
Split up the `ShufflingRef` acceleration logic into generically usable
parts and attester shuffling specific parts. The generic parts could be
used to accelerate other purposes, e.g., REST `/states/xxx/randao` API.
2023-07-31 18:12:15 +00:00
tersec 846e7c585b
Revert "Revert "generalize `ShufflingRef` acceleration logic (#5197)" (#5223)" (#5225)
This reverts commit 2ab4592a31.
2023-07-31 13:11:45 +00:00
tersec 2ab4592a31
Revert "generalize `ShufflingRef` acceleration logic (#5197)" (#5223)
This reverts commit eb3a30655b.
2023-07-31 08:05:32 +02:00
Philippe Schommers 74c993d616
feat: add support for Chiado (#5208) 2023-07-26 15:54:16 +03:00
Jacek Sieka e8379389e7
speed up state/block loading (#5207)
* speed up state/block loading

When loading blocks and states from db/era, we currently redundantly
check their CRC32 - for a state, this costs 50ms of loading time
presently (110mb uncompressed size) on a decent laptop.

* remove `maxDecompressedDbRecordSize` - not actually used on recent
data since we store the framed format - also, we're in luck: we blew
past the limit quite some time ago
* fix obsolete exception-based error checking
* avoid `zeroMem` when reading from era store

see https://github.com/status-im/nim-snappy/pull/22 for benchmarks

* bump snappy
2023-07-26 10:47:46 +03:00
Eugene Kabanov df80ae68fa
REST server metrics and connections API endpoints. (#5193)
* Add new REST endpoints to monitor REST server connections and new chronos metrics.

* Bump head versions of chronos and presto.

* Bump chronos with regression fix.

* Remove outdated tests which was supposed to test pipeline mode.

* Disable pipeline mode in resttest.

* Update copyright year.

* Upgrade test_signing_node to start use AsyncProcess instead of std library's osproc.
Bump chronos to check graceful shutdown.

* Update AllTests.

* Bump chronos.
2023-07-21 16:54:09 +02:00
Etan Kissling eb3a30655b
generalize `ShufflingRef` acceleration logic (#5197)
Split up the `ShufflingRef` acceleration logic into generically usable
parts and attester shuffling specific parts. The generic parts could be
used to accelerate other purposes, e.g., REST `/states/xxx/randao` API.
2023-07-20 10:25:39 +02:00
tersec 81c989660a
remove Bellatrix builder API support (#5162)
Co-authored-by: Etan Kissling <etan@status.im>
2023-07-20 04:37:54 +00:00
Etan Kissling da5bb96856
avoid Nim 2.0 issue when loading config (#5202)
To avoid Nim 2.0 issue https://github.com/nim-lang/Nim/issues/22284,
explicitly specify `ref SecondarySources` instead of using `auto`,
and add `{.raises.}` annotation
2023-07-19 20:26:30 +02:00
Zahary Karadjov 60f0a2f6a6
Version 23.7.0 2023-07-19 15:35:49 +03:00
Etan Kissling 971b4483c5
add `libnimbus_lc.a` C library (#5122)
Add a new C library for processing light client data based on the Nimbus
implementation. This can be used from other, non-Nimbus components.
2023-07-19 09:48:39 +02:00
Etan Kissling 346d05a95d
increase `getPayloadFromSingleEL` timeout (#5194)
When producing a local block and `runProposalForkchoiceUpdated` was
missed, `getPayloadFromSingleEL` adds additional ~500ms of latency.
Quick fix to avoid missing blocks to that.
2023-07-18 23:29:50 +03:00
Jacek Sieka b3b5238434
disable startup pruning (#5191)
it has been shown to cause long startup times - a better strategy is
needed
2023-07-18 23:29:23 +03:00
Etan Kissling dd35d2d309
delay `onSlotEnd` if there are duties (#5196)
We currently call `onSlotEnd` whenever all in-BN validator duties are
completed. VC validator duties are not awaited. When `onSlotEnd` is
processed close to the slot start, a VC may therefore miss duties.
Adding a delay before `onSlotEnd` improves this situation.
The logic can be optimized further if `ActionTracker` would track
`knownValidators` from REST separately from in-process ones.
2023-07-18 20:55:36 +02:00
Etan Kissling f98c33ad03
generalize `commonAncestor` function to `BlockId` (#5192)
To enable additional use cases, e.g., `/states/###/randao` beacon API,
`ShufflingRef` acceleration logic needs to be able to operate on parts
of the DAG that do not have `BlockRef`. Changing `commonAncestor` to
act on `BlockId` instead of `BlockRef` is a step toward that and also
simplifies the logic some more.
2023-07-18 17:37:53 +02:00
tersec 3a818ecb93
fall back to non-fcu fork choice on epoch boundaries (#5195)
* fall back to non-fcu fork choice on epoch boundaries

* Future[bool]

* fix

* Update beacon_chain/consensus_object_pools/consensus_manager.nim

Co-authored-by: Etan Kissling <etan@status.im>

* make things consistent with Opt[void] return

---------

Co-authored-by: Etan Kissling <etan@status.im>
2023-07-17 22:30:38 +02:00
Etan Kissling 2efc44a8ab
accelerate RANDAO computation for post-merge blocks (#5190)
Post-merge blocks contain all information to directly obtain RANDAO
without having to load any additional info. Take advantage of that to
further accelerate `ShufflingRef` computation. Note that it is still
necessary to verify that `blck` / `state` share a sufficiently recent
ancestor for the purpose of computing attester shufflings.

- new: 243.71s, 239.67s, 237.32s, 238.36s, 239.57s
- old: 251.33s, 234.29s, 249.28s, 237.03s, 236.78s
2023-07-15 22:16:56 +02:00
tersec 565edfa351
remove unused code (#5158)
* remove unused code

* add copyright header
2023-07-15 16:30:52 +00:00
tersec 703eead2e6
ensure the arrays in BeaconStateDiff are int-indexable in Nim 2.0 (#5189) 2023-07-13 23:25:10 +02:00
tersec 0be5b5b8f2
handle distinct nil more rigorously (#5180) 2023-07-12 17:33:19 +00:00
Etan Kissling 74bb4b1411
simplify RANDAO recovery in `ShufflingRef` acceleration (#5183)
Current RANDAO recovery logic is quite complex as it optimizes for the
minimum amount of database reads. Loading blocks isn't the bottleneck
though, so rather make the implementation more concise by avoiding the
complex strategy planning step. Note that this also prepares for an even
faster implementation for post-merge blocks in the future that extracts
RANDAO from `ExecutionPayload` directly if available, so even in cases
where efficiency is slightly lower, only historical data is affected.

`time nim c -r tests/test_blockchain_dag` (cached binary):

- new: 145.45s, 133.59s, 144.65s, 127.69s, 136.14s
- old: 149.15s, 150.84s, 135.77s, 137.49s, 133.89s
2023-07-12 17:27:05 +02:00
Jacek Sieka 0660ffcd3e
fix debug logging 2023-07-11 21:48:27 +02:00
henridf f13f23e21b
Complete Deneb bn side for /eth/v2/validator/blocks/{slot} (#5146)
* Complete Deneb bn side for /eth/v2/validator/blocks/{slot}

* Address review feedback

* More review feedback

* Tighten up when condition

* Update beacon_chain/rpc/rest_validator_api.nim

Co-authored-by: tersec <tersec@users.noreply.github.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: tersec <tersec@users.noreply.github.com>
2023-07-11 19:35:55 +00:00
Jacek Sieka a2adbf809f
Perform block pre-check before validating execution (#5169)
* Perform block pre-check before validating execution

When syncing, blocks have not been gossip-validated and are therefore
prone to trivial faults like being known-unviable, duplicate or missing
their parent.

In addition, the duplicate-block check in BlockProcessor was not
considering the quarantine flow and would therefore cause
recently-quarantined blocks to be silenty dropped when their parent
appears delaying the sync end-game and thus causing longer startup
resync time.

This PR verifies trivial conditions before performing execution
validation thus avoiding duplicates and missing parents alike.

It also ensures that the fast-sync EL mode is used for finalized blocks
even if the EL is timing out / slow to respond - this allows the CL to
complete its sync faster and switch to "normal" lock-step at the head of
the chain more quickly, thus also allowing the EL to access the latest
consensensus information earlier.

* oops

* remove unused constant
2023-07-11 18:55:51 +02:00
Jacek Sieka ca1775f725
Fetch by-root request directly from quarantine (#5167)
When the requestmanager is busy fetching blocks, the queue might get
filled with multiple entries of the same root - since there is no
deduplication, requests containing the same root multiple times will be
sent out.

Also, because the items sit in the queue for a long time potentially,
the request might be stale by the time that the manager is ready with
the previous request.

This PR removes the queue and directly fetches the blocks to download
from the quarantine which solves both problems (the quarantine already
de-duplicates and is clean of stale information).

Removing the queue for blobs is left for a future PR.

Co-authored-by: tersec <tersec@users.noreply.github.com>
2023-07-11 18:22:02 +02:00
tersec 174c33e5fa
residual cleanup from https://github.com/status-im/nimbus-eth2/pull/5152 (#5181) 2023-07-11 14:36:37 +00:00
Jacek Sieka 185684daf8
simplify deposit syncing message (#5177)
and make it less alarming since there's no action required from the user
typically
2023-07-11 08:01:56 +02:00
Jacek Sieka 1bac029935
avoid unnecessary buffer zero:ing (#5178) 2023-07-11 08:01:45 +02:00
tersec a1ddd447bc
use correct import name for kzg4844 (#5179) 2023-07-10 23:55:40 +00:00
Etan Kissling 5115aaedb7
early exit `commonAncestor` when comparing with `finalizedHead` (#5174)
* early exit `commonAncestor` when comparing with `finalizedHead`

As all `BlockRef` lead to `finalizedHead` (`parent == nil`),
can shortcut in that situation and immediately return `finalizedHead`
if passed as one of the arguments.

* typo in comment

* add test from #5152

Co-authored-by: tersec <tersec@users.noreply.github.com>

* add note about test complexity

* regenerate test summary

---------

Co-authored-by: tersec <tersec@users.noreply.github.com>
2023-07-10 20:36:25 +00:00
henridf 86e33b0a3f
Remove stale denebImplementationMissing (#5173)
This should have been removed as part of #5137
2023-07-10 17:17:33 +02:00
henridf 23edc4f960
Finish readValue for deneb RestPublishedBeaconBlockBody (#5172)
(Stray piece that got left behind a previous PR...)
2023-07-10 14:57:11 +00:00
tersec 49056c3e39
use v1.3.0 stability subnet behavior when appropriate (#5156) 2023-07-07 04:16:12 +00:00
Jacek Sieka 862897124a
rest: allow state root lookups up to 8k slots from head (#5155)
* rest: allow state root lookups up to 8k slots from head

* avoid int, clean up error messages
2023-07-06 12:53:35 +02:00
Eugene Kabanov ac1b02698a
VC: Use scoring function to select best attestation data when using multiple BNs. (#5101)
* Initial commit.

* Move score selection log statement to debug level.

* Fix proper float64 log format.

* Cleanup imports and legacy code.

* Address review comments.

* Address review comments.

* Fix scoring function.

* Address review comments.

* Address review comments 2.
Fix registerBlock post-rebase issues.

* Simplify innerLoop decision making.

* Make getAttestationDataScore() more testable.
Add tests for getAttestationDataScore().

* Add modified AllTests copy.
2023-07-06 11:14:22 +02:00
tersec 1e2d3b12c4
update some consensus-specs ref URLs to v1.4.0-beta.0 (#5163) 2023-07-05 16:02:55 +00:00
tersec 583eb4db17
work around some CastSizes warnings and fix unreachable code warnings (#5149) 2023-06-30 21:34:04 +02:00
tersec 0be95571a7
update some consensus spec URLs to v1.4.0-beta.0 (#5150) 2023-06-30 16:12:54 +00:00
tersec b4c4f0955e
https://github.com/ethereum/consensus-specs/pull/3421 https://github.com/ethereum/execution-apis/pull/420 (#5147) 2023-06-30 08:14:20 +00:00
henridf 99264d7507
Local validator proposals (#5137)
* Implement local validator block proposals

* Address review feedback

* Fix rebase issue
2023-06-30 07:39:41 +00:00
tersec ba94dc849f
opt-out support for v1.4.0 attestation stability subnets (#5128)
* opt-out support for v1.4.0 attestation stability subnets

* document debug-prefix-flag-policy and remove temporary from flag name
2023-06-30 05:23:15 +00:00
tersec d5a6d51ede
Web3Signer support only for only Bellatrix and later (#5107)
Co-authored-by: Etan Kissling <etan@status.im>
2023-06-29 09:36:43 +00:00
tersec dc5687093f
update gossip validation for v1.4.0-beta.0 (#5133)
Co-authored-by: Etan Kissling <etan@status.im>
2023-06-29 08:34:21 +00:00
henridf 7b0e3b1c04
Review feedbac from #5106 (#5141) 2023-06-29 01:17:54 +00:00
henridf 1234900065
Add blob handling to message router (#5106)
* Add blob handling to message router

* address review feedback

* Fix typos
2023-06-28 17:55:31 +00:00
Etan Kissling 41b93ae57a
fix code for Nim `v1.6.14` compatibility (#5131)
With `v1.6.14` there is compilation issue in `trusted_node_sync` where
a type is not inferred automatically anymore for a `nil` instance.
Fix it so we can bump the compiler.

See https://github.com/status-im/nimbus-build-system/pull/63
2023-06-28 17:21:43 +00:00
Eugene Kabanov 5e1a0eac85
VC: Runtime config (#5130)
* Make VC able to understand any type of `/eth/v1/config/spec` response without any changes in source code.
Update compatibility checking.
Now VC is able to obtain any constant from `spec` call.

* Remove RestSpecVC declaration.
2023-06-28 15:33:38 +02:00
Eugene Kabanov c534a285b9
Fix polling block monitor from deadlocks when connection has been lost. (#5109)
Fix events block monitor from losing connection forever.
Add node to block received log statement.
2023-06-28 15:33:21 +02:00
Eugene Kabanov c2c5d80a4f
VC: Remote BN clock offset monitoring. (#4846)
* Initial commit.

* Add algorithm in comment.
Remove delays.
Fix logging statement issues.
Change update from epoch to slot.

* Obtain timestamp earlier.

* Add processing delays into algorithm.

* Fix time offset logging to produce integers instead of strings.

* Address review comments.

* Fix copyright year.
Fix updateStatus().

* Remove fields from Slot start log statement.
Fix issues when BN do not support Nimbus Extensions.
Rename metric name and type change.

* Add beacon role to disable time offset check manually.
2023-06-28 15:33:07 +02:00
tersec bf575aac57
make OnFooBlockAdded callback types generic (#5134) 2023-06-28 13:30:49 +00:00
Zahary Karadjov 970f5dfc4e
Merge branch 'stable' into unstable 2023-06-27 05:40:58 +03:00
Zahary Karadjov 187e1a0633
Version 23.6.1 2023-06-27 03:58:14 +03:00
Jacek Sieka 17e74c0c8b
don't check legacy tables for pruning (#5116)
These tables can't be deleted from (read-only) and would be too slow to
delete from anyway due to the inefficient storage format in use.

* slow down startup clearing too
* remove unused del function
2023-06-26 19:30:45 +03:00
henridf ac3d8939a8
Add Deneb handling to state_transition.makeBeaconBlock() (#5118)
* Add Deneb handling to state_transition.makeBeaconBlock()

* review feedback
2023-06-26 16:05:02 +00:00
tersec a2bdc2d723
revert 2023-06-26 08:38:05 +00:00
tersec dbd7611983
not a real change 2023-06-26 08:36:39 +00:00
tersec ba597ef0a2
per-validator payload builder configuration (#5062) 2023-06-25 12:00:17 +00:00
tersec 614202e30d
automated consensus spec URL updating to v1.4.0-beta.0 (#5121) 2023-06-24 15:43:30 +00:00
Jacek Sieka d9bff54d57
don't check legacy tables for pruning (#5116)
These tables can't be deleted from (read-only) and would be too slow to
delete from anyway due to the inefficient storage format in use.

* slow down startup clearing too
* remove unused del function
2023-06-24 16:14:28 +02:00
tersec 9dbf63d8ca
use v1.4.0-beta.0 consensus spec test vectors (#5120) 2023-06-24 12:27:15 +00:00
tersec b62664915e
consensus spec v1.4.0 attestation stability subnets (#5092) 2023-06-23 09:30:46 +00:00
henridf fa212515f5
Implement validor client proposals for Deneb (#5094) 2023-06-23 09:30:16 +00:00