Commit Graph

86 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
tersec f0321d2eb5
remove inspector (#2737) 2021-07-29 14:00:04 +00:00
Eugene Kabanov f9cd98702e
Fix getBlockHeaders() should return array. (#2732)
Fix tests.
2021-07-24 19:22:05 +02:00
Jacek Sieka 3f9c1fdf4e
More RuntimeConfig cleanup (#2716)
* remove from BeaconChainDB (doesn't depend on runtime config)
* eth2-testnets -> eth2-networks
* use `cfg` name throughout
2021-07-13 16:27:10 +02:00
Jacek Sieka 23eea197f6
Implement split preset/config support (#2710)
* Implement split preset/config support

This is the initial bulk refactor to introduce runtime config values in
a number of places, somewhat replacing the existing mechanism of loading
network metadata.

It still needs more work, this is the initial refactor that introduces
runtime configuration in some of the places that need it.

The PR changes the way presets and constants work, to match the spec. In
particular, a "preset" now refers to the compile-time configuration
while a "cfg" or "RuntimeConfig" is the dynamic part.

A single binary can support either mainnet or minimal, but not both.
Support for other presets has been removed completely (can be readded,
in case there's need).

There's a number of outstanding tasks:

* `SECONDS_PER_SLOT` still needs fixing
* loading custom runtime configs needs redoing
* checking constants against YAML file

* yeerongpilly support

`build/nimbus_beacon_node --network=yeerongpilly --discv5:no --log-level=DEBUG`

* load fork epoch from config

* fix fork digest sent in status
* nicer error string for request failures
* fix tools

* one more

* fixup

* fixup

* fixup

* use "standard" network definition folder in local testnet

Files are loaded from their standard locations, including genesis etc,
to conform to the format used in the `eth2-networks` repo.

* fix launch scripts, allow unknown config values

* fix base config of rest test

* cleanups

* bundle mainnet config using common loader
* fix spec links and names
* only include supported preset in binary

* drop yeerongpilly, add altair-devnet-0, support boot_enr.yaml
2021-07-12 15:01:38 +02:00
tersec 445def6c8b
block_clearance, ncli, and ncli_db Altair state saving (#2672)
* block_clearance, ncli, and ncli_db Altair state saving

* avoid invalidating SSZ hash caches with every assignment
2021-06-24 18:34:08 +00:00
tersec ae1abf24af
add Altair support to block quarantine/clearance and block_sim (#2662)
* add Altair support to the block quarantine

* switch some spec/datatypes imports to spec/datatypes/base

* add Altair support to block_clearance

* allow runtime configuration of Altair transition slot

* enable Altair in block_sim, including in CI
2021-06-23 14:43:18 +00:00
Eugene Kabanov f8eb906b51
Add CONFIG_NAME parameter to REST API /eth/v1/config/spec response. (#2652)
* Add CONFIG_NAME parameter to /eth/v1/config/spec response.

* Add missed comma.

* Use `const_preset` instead of CONFIG_NAME.
2021-06-18 14:43:54 +02:00
tersec 9616220280
implement Altair attestation pool cache init (#2659)
* implement Altair attestation pool cache init

* remove code duplication around previous/current epoch updates
2021-06-17 17:13:14 +00:00
tersec 146fa48454
use ForkedHashedBeaconState in StateData (#2634)
* use ForkedHashedBeaconState in StateData

* fix FAR_FUTURE_EPOCH -> slot overflow; almost always use assign()

* avoid stack allocation in maybeUpgradeStateToAltair()

* create and use dispatch functions for check_attester_slashing(), check_proposer_slashing(), and check_voluntary_exit()

* use getStateRoot() instead of various state.data.hbsPhase0.root

* remove withStateVars.hashedState(), which doesn't work as a design anymore

* introduce spec/datatypes/altair into beacon_chain_db

* fix inefficient codegen for getStateField(largeStateField)

* state_transition_slots() doesn't either need/use blocks or runtime presets

* combine process_slots(HBS)/state_transition_slots(HBS) which differ only in last-slot htr optimization

* getStateField(StateData, ...) was replaced by getStateField(ForkedHashedBeaconState, ...)

* fix rollback

* switch some state_transition(), process_slots, makeTestBlocks(), etc to use ForkedHashedBeaconState

* remove state_transition(phase0.HashedBeaconState)

* remove process_slots(phase0.HashedBeaconState)

* remove state_transition_block(phase0.HashedBeaconState)

* remove unused callWithBS(); separate case expression from if statement

* switch back from nested-ref-object construction to (ref Foo)(Bar())
2021-06-11 20:51:46 +03:00
tersec 8ebd496fbe
Altair transition tests (#2624)
* Working Altair transition tests

* with fixed upstream test vectors, remove state root workaround

* switch upgrade_to_altair() to returning a reference

* remove test_state_transition

* fix invalid fork state/block combinations error messages

* avoid memory copies by reintroducing state_transition_slots(var SomeHashedBeaconState)
2021-06-04 10:38:00 +00:00
tersec 28a5bca71a
split state_transition() into slots/block parts and use only block where appropriate (#2630) 2021-06-03 11:42:25 +02:00
Zahary Karadjov 0afb5be6b4 A simple script for fetching detailed deposit data 2021-05-28 19:34:20 +03:00
Jacek Sieka d16da06c92 ncli_db: validator performance database tool
Record attestation performance per epoch in sqlite database
2021-05-27 19:14:26 +03:00
Jacek Sieka 584fcd50c1
ncli: fix inclusion distance statistic (#2587) 2021-05-24 10:40:45 +02:00
tersec 0b0bfd1de0
use StateData in place of BeaconState outside state transition code (#2551)
* use StateData in place of BeaconState outside state transition code

* propagate more StateData usage

* remove withStateVars().state

* wrap get_beacon_committee(BeaconState, ...) as gbc(StateData, ...)

* switch makeAttestation() to use StateData

* use StateData wrapper/dispatcher for get_committee_count_per_slot()

* convert AttestationCache.init(), weak subjectivity functions, and updateValidatorMetrics()

* add get_shuffled_active_validator_indices(StateData) and get_block_root_at_slot(StateData)

* switch makeAttestationData() to StateData

* sync AllTests-mainnet.md after rebase
2021-05-21 09:23:28 +00:00
Zahary Karadjov b7aa30adfd
Merge stable into unstable 2021-05-20 13:50:40 +03:00
Jacek Sieka 97f4e1fffe
Db1 cont (#2573)
* Revert "Revert "Upgrade database schema" (#2570)"

This reverts commit 6057c2ffb4.

* ssz: fix loading empty lists into existing instances

Not a problem earlier because we didn't reuse instances

* bump nim-eth

* bump nim-web3
2021-05-17 18:37:26 +02:00
tersec 6057c2ffb4
Revert "Upgrade database schema" (#2570)
This reverts commit 22ddf74752.
2021-05-17 06:34:44 +00:00
Jacek Sieka 22ddf74752 Upgrade database schema
The `kvstore` design we're using now turns out to not be the best way to
use `sqlite` - in particular, there are some significant benefits to
using rowid in certain situations and to keep data in separate tables.

With this branch, there are massive improvements in startup time
(seconds instead of minutes) and state/block storage and pruning times
(milliseconds instead of seconds) - these improvements can in particular
be seen on slow drives and translate directly into better attestation
performance.

* update kvstore to new keyspace design
* remove `DirStoreRef` and the hidden `--state-db-kind` option - this
was an experiment to store large blobs in files, but with the new
kvstore, there's no compelling reason to do so
* remove `DbMap` - unused and would need updating for new keyspace
design
* introduce separate tables for each data type (blocks, states etc)
* remove "WITHOUT ROWID" pessimization for tables with large blobs
* close DbSeq statements explicitly (and earlier)
* store beacon block summaries in separate table, without SSZ
compression and load them all with single query on startup
* stop storing backwards compat full states
* mark genesis beacon block as trusted
* avoid faststreams when loading SSZ data
* remove `DisagreementBehavior` (unused)
2021-05-14 20:05:23 +03:00
Jacek Sieka 867d8f3223
Perform attestation check before broadcast (#2550)
Currently, we have a bit of a convoluted flow where when sending
attestations, we start broadcasting them over gossip then pass them to
the attestation validation to include them in the local attestation pool
- it should be the other way around: we should be checking attestations
_before_ gossipping them - this serves as an additional safety net to
ensure that we don't publish junk - this becomes more important when
publishing attestations from the API.

Also, the REST API was performing its own validation meaning
attestations coming from REST would be validated twice - finally, the
JSON RPC wasn't pre-validating and would happily broadcast invalid
attestations.

* Unified attestation production pipeline with the same flow for gossip,
locally and API-produced attestations: all are now validated and entered
into the pool, then broadcast/republished
* Refactor subnet handling with specific SubnetId alias, streamlining
where subnets are computed, avoiding the need to pass around the number
of active validators
* Move some of the subnet handling code to eth2_network
* Use BitArray throughout for subnet handling
2021-05-10 09:13:36 +02:00
tersec 39da640beb
use getStateField() in ncli_db (#2549) 2021-05-07 13:14:20 +00:00
Jacek Sieka 646923c3dd
add attestation stats tool to ncli_db (#2539)
This also makes future efforts to provide metrics and logs for
attestation efficiency easier

* Export rewards from epoch transition
* Use less memory for reward calculation (bool -> set[enum], field
alignment)
* Reuse reward memory when replaying, avoiding spike
* Allow replaying any range in ncli_db benchmark
2021-05-07 13:36:21 +02:00
Jacek Sieka 4d74c742da
move ENRForkID into `spec` (#2538)
* move ENRForkID into `spec`

also get rid of strformat in topic formation and fix some case
discrepancies

* also move `Eth2Metadata`
2021-05-04 17:28:48 +02:00
Eugene Kabanov 0c3302b826
REST API test framework and tests. (#2492)
* REST API test framework and tests.

* Fix ValidatorIndex tests to properly handle int32, but not uint32 values.

* Fix tests to follow latest REST fixes.

* refactor restapi.sh

and add it to the test suite

* Fix issues.
Add delay timeout which is required.

* Fix restapi.sh script for Windows.

Co-authored-by: Ștefan Talpalaru <stefantalpalaru@yahoo.com>
2021-04-27 23:46:24 +03:00
Dmitriy Ryajov ce48644b3b use builders 2021-04-12 20:28:39 +03:00
Jacek Sieka beceb060c4
Write state diffs to separate table (and experimentally, files instead of db) (#2460) 2021-04-06 21:56:45 +03:00
Jacek Sieka 3cb31e66b4
set upper bound on EpochRef cache (#2403)
* set upper bound on EpochRef cache

* max 32 EpochRef instances
* less memory waste in BlockRef by removing EpochRef seq that is mostly
unused (~20mb)
* less memory waste in dag block lookup by not keeping an extra copy of
digest (~70mb)
* fix `==` and `$` for Eth2Digest
* remove `ChainDAG.tmpState` (~50mb?)

all in all, this branch cuts mainnet memory usage by ~160-180mb and puts
limits on EpochRef cache usage - where normally it hovered around 950mb
before, it's now sitting at 600-700mb on my machine.

* docs
2021-03-17 11:17:15 +01:00
tersec 8def2486b0
immutable validator database factoring (#2297)
* initial immutable validator database factoring

* remove changes from chain_dag: this abstraction properly belongs in beacon_chain_db

* add merging mutable/immutable validator portions; individually test database roundtripping of immutable validators and states-sans-immutable-validators

* update test summaries

* use stew/assign2 instead of Nim assignment

* add reading/writing of immutable validators in chaindag

* remove unused import

* replace chunked k/v store of immutable validators with per-row SQL table storage

* use List instead of HashList

* un-stub some ncli_db code so that it uses

* switch HashArray to array; move BeaconStateNoImmutableValidators from datatypes to beacon_chain_db

* begin only-mutable-part state storage

* uncomment some assigns

* work around https://github.com/nim-lang/Nim/issues/17253

* fix most of the issues/oversights; local sim runs again

* fix test suite by adding missing beaconstate field to copy function

* have ncli bench also store immutable validators

* extract some immutable-validator-specific code from the beacon chain db module

* add more rigorous database state roundtripping, with changing validator sets

* adjust ncli_db to use new schema

* simplify putState/getState by moving all immutable validator accounting into beacon state DB

* remove redundant test case and move code to immutable-beacon-chain module

* more efficient, but still brute-force, mutable+immutable validator merging

* reuse BeaconState in getState

* ensure HashList/HashArray caches are cleared when reusing getState buffers; add ncli_db and a unit test to verify this

* HashList.clear() -> HashList.clearCache()

* only copy incrementally necessary immutable validators

* increase strictness of test cases and fix/work around resulting HashList cache invalidation issues

* remove explanatory scaffolding

* allow for storage of full (with all validators) states for backwards/forwards-compatibility

* adjust DbSeq type usage

* store full, with-validators, state every 64 epochs to enable reverting versions

* reduce memory allocation and intermediate objects in state storage codepath

* eliminate allocation/copying through intermediate BeaconStateNoImmutableValidators objects

* skip benchmarking initial genesis-validator-heavy state store

* always store new-style state and sometimes old-style state

* document intent behind BeaconState/Validator type-punnery

* more accurate failure message on SQLite in-memory database initialization failure
2021-03-15 14:11:51 +00:00
Jacek Sieka aabdd34704
e2store: add era format (#2382)
Era files contain 8192 blocks and a state corresponding to the length of
the array holding block roots in the state, meaning that each block is
verifiable using the pubkeys and block roots from the state. Of course,
one would need to know the root of the state as well, which is available
in the first block of the _next_ file - or known from outside.

This PR also adds an implementation to write e2s, e2i and era files, as
well as a python script to inspect them.

All in all, the format is very similar to what goes on in the network
requests meaning it can trivially serve as a backing format for serving
said requests.

Mainnet, up to the first 671k slots, take up 3.5gb - in each era file,
the BeaconState contributes about 9mb at current validator set sizes, up
from ~3mb in the early blocks, for a grand total of ~558mb for the 82 eras
tested - this overhead could potentially be calculated but one would lose
the ability to verify individual blocks (eras could still be verified using
historical roots).

```
-rw-rw-r--. 1 arnetheduck arnetheduck   16  5 mar 11.47 ethereum2-mainnet-00000000-00000001.e2i
-rw-rw-r--. 1 arnetheduck arnetheduck 1,8M  5 mar 11.47 ethereum2-mainnet-00000000-00000001.e2s
-rw-rw-r--. 1 arnetheduck arnetheduck  65K  5 mar 11.47 ethereum2-mainnet-00000001-00000001.e2i
-rw-rw-r--. 1 arnetheduck arnetheduck  18M  5 mar 11.47 ethereum2-mainnet-00000001-00000001.e2s
...
-rw-rw-r--. 1 arnetheduck arnetheduck  65K  5 mar 11.52 ethereum2-mainnet-00000051-00000001.e2i
-rw-rw-r--. 1 arnetheduck arnetheduck  68M  5 mar 11.52 ethereum2-mainnet-00000051-00000001.e2s
-rw-rw-r--. 1 arnetheduck arnetheduck  61K  5 mar 11.11 ethereum2-mainnet-00000052-00000001.e2i
-rw-rw-r--. 1 arnetheduck arnetheduck  62M  5 mar 11.11 ethereum2-mainnet-00000052-00000001.e2s
```
2021-03-15 11:31:39 +01:00
Dustin Brody 97504fdb9d ncli_db pruneDatabase checkpointing; remove onSlotEnd lookaheadTime 2021-03-12 23:15:46 +02:00
tersec 6533999c82
benchmark state loading in ncli_db (#2400) 2021-03-12 10:02:09 +00:00
kdeme 5f750f84b4 Use setupAddress for better IP and ports configuration 2021-03-06 00:09:09 +02:00
Mamy Ratsimbazafy d47f53cd9d
Reorg (5/5) (#2377)
* Reorg things left into networking and gossip_processing

* time -> beacon_clock

* fix builds
2021-03-05 14:12:00 +01:00
Mamy Ratsimbazafy 5d7f9c3a04
Consensus object pools [reorg 4/5] (#2374)
* Add documentation

* make test doesn't try to build the beacon node :/
2021-03-04 10:13:44 +01:00
Mamy Ratsimbazafy 2f17ac7b64
Move SSZ, deposit_contracts & eth1_monitor [reorg files 3/5] (#2371)
* move deposit_contract

* Move SSZ

* fix ssz import in tests

* move also eth1_monitor

* forgot to delete the original

* fix comma [skip ci]

* Fix "make" & tools imports

* Fix import

* Fix import again

* rename deposit_contract -> eth1

* Revert ssz move to subfolder

* path fixes [skip ci]
2021-03-03 07:23:05 +01:00
Mamy Ratsimbazafy 19775c1b22
Move tools (#2370)
* Delete tracing and styled stacktraces

* Move NBC tooling to ncli folder

* fix inspector import [skip ci]

* fix comma
2021-03-02 15:02:10 +01:00
Mamy Ratsimbazafy 3276dfc683
Consolidate modules by areas [part 1] (#2365)
* Move sync in subfolder

* move validator related thingies in validators

* fix binary builds

* update bounds comment [skip ci]
2021-03-02 11:27:45 +01:00
tersec 5cab17dc1a
database state storage benchmarking via ncli_db (#2312)
* database state storage benchmarking via ncli_db

* more cleanups from immutable validator state branch

* unexport some eth2_network constants and remove unused variables/templates

* make two PeerScore constants public
2021-02-15 17:40:00 +01:00
Mamy Ratsimbazafy 03f47c8f2f
Slashing protection refactor - EIP 3076 (#2094)
* Create CLI tool for slashing export

* Use SQLite as a DB instead of a KV-store

* Keeps v1 and v2 DBs around

* Uses the same schema as Lighthouse v1.1.0

* Passes all interchange tests + skeleton of finalization pruning

* Removes tests that would violate v5 / minimal slashing DB and MinSlot rules

* Migration tool added using low-watermark scheme for faster migration of large number of validators
2021-02-09 17:23:06 +02:00
Jacek Sieka 5713a3ce4c
performance fixes (#2259)
* performance fixes

* don't mark tree cache as dirty on read-only List accesses
* store only blob in memory for keys and signatures, parse blob lazily
* compare public keys by blob instead of parsing / converting to raw
* compare Eth2Digest using non-constant-time comparison
* avoid some unnecessary validator copying

This branch will in particular speed up deposit processing which has
been slowing down block replay.

Pre (mainnet, 1600 blocks):

```
All time are ms
     Average,       StdDev,          Min,          Max,      Samples,         Test
Validation is turned off meaning that no BLS operations are performed
    3450.269,        0.000,     3450.269,     3450.269,            1, Initialize DB
       0.417,        0.822,        0.036,       21.098,         1400, Load block from database
      16.521,        0.000,       16.521,       16.521,            1, Load state from database
      27.906,       50.846,        8.104,     1507.633,         1350, Apply block
      52.617,       37.029,       20.640,      135.938,           50, Apply epoch block
```

Post:

```
    3502.715,        0.000,     3502.715,     3502.715,            1, Initialize DB
       0.080,        0.560,        0.035,       21.015,         1400, Load block from database
      17.595,        0.000,       17.595,       17.595,            1, Load state from database
      15.706,       11.028,        8.300,      107.537,         1350, Apply block
      33.217,       12.622,       17.331,       60.580,           50, Apply epoch block
```

* more perf fixes

* load EpochRef cache into StateCache more aggressively
* point out security concern with public key cache
* reuse proposer index from state when processing block
* avoid genericAssign in a few more places
* don't parse key when signature is unparseable
* fix `==` overload for Eth2Digest
* preallocate validator list when getting active validators
* speed up proposer index calculation a little bit
* reuse cache when replaying blocks in ncli_db
* avoid a few more copying loops

```
     Average,       StdDev,          Min,          Max,      Samples,         Test
Validation is turned off meaning that no BLS operations are performed
    3279.158,        0.000,     3279.158,     3279.158,            1, Initialize DB
       0.072,        0.357,        0.035,       13.400,         1400, Load block from database
      17.295,        0.000,       17.295,       17.295,            1, Load state from database
       5.918,        9.896,        0.198,       98.028,         1350, Apply block
      15.888,       10.951,        7.902,       39.535,           50, Apply epoch block
       0.000,        0.000,        0.000,        0.000,            0, Database block store
```

* clear full balance cache before processing rewards and penalties

```
All time are ms
     Average,       StdDev,          Min,          Max,      Samples,         Test
Validation is turned off meaning that no BLS operations are performed
    3947.901,        0.000,     3947.901,     3947.901,            1, Initialize DB
       0.124,        0.506,        0.026,      202.370,       363345, Load block from database
      97.614,        0.000,       97.614,       97.614,            1, Load state from database
       0.186,        0.188,        0.012,       99.561,       357262, Advance slot, non-epoch
      14.161,        5.966,        1.099,      395.511,        11524, Advance slot, epoch
       1.372,        4.170,        0.017,      276.401,       363345, Apply block, no slot processing
       0.000,        0.000,        0.000,        0.000,            0, Database block store
```
2021-01-25 13:04:18 +01:00
tersec 027e272007
fix tools/all build (#2010) 2020-11-13 13:57:48 +01:00
Zahary Karadjov 5f6bdc6709 Store all deposit-derived data in memory 2020-10-15 20:15:51 +03:00
Zahary Karadjov e6320e5881 Address #1584 Don't keep all deposits in memory (persist them to disk) 2020-10-15 20:15:51 +03:00
Jacek Sieka 6b9419e547
fix db growth on attestation processing (#1860)
It turns out that we often save lots of states in the database that are
the result of empty slot processing only - here, we make sure to only
save a state if a block follows - this fixes several issues:

* empty slot states are not always pruned leading to state database size
explosion
* storing states is (very) slow which slows down processing in general,
so we should only do it when it's likely to be useful
* attestation processing doesn't get stuck on saving random states that
won't appear in the chain history
2020-10-15 14:28:44 +02:00
tersec b79e5f8af5
update nim-beacon-chain to nimbus-eth2 in beacon_chain/, ncli/, tests/, and README.md (#1843) 2020-10-08 19:02:05 +00:00
tersec a1a8da82b4
replace assertion with warning message (#1776) 2020-09-29 17:15:49 +02:00
Jacek Sieka dcf8a6b05d
improve slot processing speeds (#1670)
about 40% better slot processing times (with LTO enabled) - these don't
do BLS but are used
heavily during replay (state transition = slot + block transition)

tests using a recent medalla state and advancing it 1000 slots:

```
./ncli slots --preState2:state-302271-3c1dbf19-c1f944bf.ssz --slot:1000
--postState2:xx.ssz
```
pre:

```

All time are ms
Average,       StdDev,          Min,          Max,      Samples,
Test
Validation is turned off meaning that no BLS operations are performed
39.236,        0.000,       39.236,       39.236,            1,
Load state from file
0.049,        0.002,        0.046,        0.063,          968,
Apply slot
256.504,       81.008,      213.471,      591.902,           32,
Apply epoch slot
28.597,        0.000,       28.597,       28.597,            1,
Save state to file
```

cast:
```
All time are ms
Average,       StdDev,          Min,          Max,      Samples,
Test
Validation is turned off meaning that no BLS operations are performed
37.079,        0.000,       37.079,       37.079,            1,
Load state from file
0.042,        0.002,        0.040,        0.090,          968,
Apply slot
215.552,       68.763,      180.155,      500.103,           32,
Apply epoch slot
25.106,        0.000,       25.106,       25.106,            1,
Save state to file
```

cast+rewards:
```
All time are ms
Average,       StdDev,          Min,          Max,      Samples,
Test
Validation is turned off meaning that no BLS operations are performed
40.049,        0.000,       40.049,       40.049,            1,
Load state from file
0.048,        0.001,        0.045,        0.060,          968,
Apply slot
164.981,       76.273,      142.099,      477.868,           32,
Apply epoch slot
28.498,        0.000,       28.498,       28.498,            1,
Save state to file
```

cast+rewards+shr
```
All time are ms
Average,       StdDev,          Min,          Max,      Samples,
Test
Validation is turned off meaning that no BLS operations are performed
12.898,        0.000,       12.898,       12.898,            1,
Load state from file
0.039,        0.002,        0.038,        0.054,          968,
Apply slot
139.971,       68.797,      120.088,      428.844,           32,
Apply epoch slot
24.761,        0.000,       24.761,       24.761,            1,
Save state to file

```
2020-09-16 20:59:33 +00:00
tersec aca1a318f2
cleanly close kvstore databases and bump nim-eth (#1630)
* cleanly close kvstore databases

* close databases for all subcommands and during error conditions
2020-09-12 05:35:58 +00:00
tersec 48893f1c2e
add ncli_db subcommand to prune database of unnecessary blocks and states (#1593)
* add ncli_db subcommand to prune database of unnecessary blocks, states, and state roots

* tweak comments

* reduce default aggressiveness in pruning old states

* move copyPrunedDatabase() to ncli_db, as it's not generally useful as part of beacon_chain_db and doesn't use any internal interfaces
2020-09-11 15:20:34 +02:00
Viktor Kirilov 67d73c4c60 added the --network=<x> option to the tools for which it matters 2020-09-01 12:02:22 +03:00