Vulkan-Docs/appendices/memorymodel.txt

// Copyright (c) 2017-2018 Khronos Group. This work is licensed under a
// Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License; see
// http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

[appendix]
[[memory-model]]
= Memory Model

[[memory-model-agent]]
== Agent

_Operation_ is a general term for any task that is executed on the system.

NOTE: An operation is by definition something that is executed, thus if an
instruction is skipped due to flow control it does not constitute an
operation.

Each operation is executed by a particular _agent_.
Possible agents include each shader invocation, each host thread, and each
fixed-function stage of the pipeline.


[[memory-model-memory-location]]
== Memory Location

A _memory location_ identifies unique storage for 8 bits of data.
Memory operations access a _set of memory locations_ consisting of one or
more memory locations at a time, e.g. an operation accessing a 32-bit
integer in memory would read/write a set of four memory locations.
Two sets of memory locations _overlap_ if the intersection of their sets of
memory locations is non-empty.
A memory operation must: not affect memory at a memory location not within
its set of memory locations.

Memory locations for buffers and images are explicitly allocated in
VkDeviceMemory objects, and are implicitly allocated for SPIR-V variables in
each shader invocation.

[[memory-model-allocation]]
== Allocation

The values stored in newly allocated memory locations are determined by a
SPIR-V variable's initializer, if present, or else are undefined.
At the time an allocation is created there have been no
<<memory-model-memory-operation,memory operations>> to any of its memory
locations.
The initialization is not considered to be a memory operation.

NOTE: For tessellation control shader output variables, a consequence of
initialization not being considered a memory operation is that some
implementations may need to insert a barrier between the initialization of
the output variables and any reads of those variables.

[[memory-model-memory-operation]]
== Memory Operation

For an operation A and memory location M:

  * [[memory-model-access-read]] A _reads_ M if and only if the data stored
    in M is an input to A.
  * [[memory-model-access-write]] A _writes_ M if and only if the data
    output from A is stored to M.
  * [[memory-model-access-access]] A _accesses_ M if and only if it either
    reads or writes (or both) M.

NOTE: A write whose value is the same as what was already in those memory
locations is still considered to be a write and has all the same effects.

[[memory-model-references]]
== Reference

A _reference_ is an object that a particular agent can: use to access a set
of memory locations.
On the host, a reference is a host virtual address.
On the device, a reference is:

  * The descriptor that a variable is bound to, for variables in Image,
    Uniform, or StorageBuffer storage classes.
    If the variable is an array (or array of arrays, etc.) then each element
    of the array may: be a unique reference.
  * The variable itself for variables in other storage classes.

Two memory accesses through distinct references may: require availability
and visibility operations as defined
<<memory-model-location-ordered,below>>.

[[memory-model-program-order]]
== Program-Order

A _dynamic instance_ of an instruction is defined in SPIR-V
(https://www.khronos.org/registry/spir-v/specs/unified1/SPIRV.html#DynamicInstance)
as a way of referring to a particular execution of a static instruction.
Program-order is an ordering on dynamic instances of instructions executed
by a single shader invocation:

  * (Basic block): If instructions A and B are in the same basic block, and
    A is listed in the module before B, then the n'th dynamic instance of A
    is program-ordered before the n'th dynamic instance of B.
  * (Branch): The dynamic instance of a branch or switch instruction is
    program-ordered before the dynamic instance of the OpLabel instruction
    to which it transfers control.
  * (Call entry): The dynamic instance of a function call instruction is
    program-ordered before the dynamic instances of the
    code:OpFunctionParameter instructions and the body of the called
    function.
  * (Call exit): The dynamic instance of the instruction following a
    function call instruction is program-ordered after the dynamic instance
    of the return instruction executed by the called function.
  * (Transitive Closure): If dynamic instance A of any instruction is
    program-ordered before dynamic instance B of any instruction and B is
    program-ordered before dynamic instance C of any instruction then A is
    program-ordered before C.
  * (Complete definition): No other dynamic instances are program-ordered.

For instructions executed on the host, the source language defines the
program-order relation (e.g. as "sequenced-before").

[[memory-model-scope]]
== Scope

A _scope_ describes a set of shader invocations, where each such set is a
_scope instance_.
Scopes are defined hierarchically such that a more inclusive scope includes
one or more sets of less inclusive scope instances.
The scopes defined by SPIR-V are as follows, defined from most inclusive to
least inclusive:

  * code:CrossDevice identifies all shader invocations in a Vulkan instance
    across all shader launches, and all host threads interacting with that
    instance.
  * code:Device identifes all shader invocations that execute on a given
    device, including those from different shader launches.
  * code:QueueFamilyKHR identifes all shader invocations that execute on any
    queue in a given queue family, including those from different shader
    launches.
  * code:Workgroup identifies all invocations in a single workgroup.
  * code:Subgroup identifies all invocations in a single subgroup.
  * code:Invocation identifies a single invocation.

Atomic and barrier instructions include scopes which identify sets of shader
invocations that must: obey the requested ordering and atomicity rules of
the operation, as defined below.

[[memory-model-atomic-operation]]
== Atomic Operation

An _atomic operation_ on the device is any SPIR-V operation whose name
begins with code:OpAtomic.
An atomic operation on the host is any operation performed with an
std::atomic typed object.

Each atomic operation has a memory <<memory-model-scope,scope>> and a
<<memory-model-memory-semantics,semantics>>.
Informally, the scope determines which other agents it is atomic with
respect to, and the <<memory-model-memory-semantics,semantics>> constrains
the ordering of other memory accesses.
Device atomic operations have explicit scopes and semantics.
Each host atomic operation implicitly uses the code:CrossDevice scope, and
uses a memory semantics equivalent to a C++ std::memory_order value of
relaxed, acquire, release, acq_rel, or seq_cst.

Two atomic operations A and B are _potentially-mutually-ordered_ if and only
if all of the following are true:

  * They access the same set of memory locations.
  * They use the same reference.
  * A is in the instance of B's memory scope.
  * B is in the instance of A's memory scope.

Two atomic operations A and B are _mutually-ordered_ if and only if they are
potentially-mutually-ordered and any of the following are true:

  * A and B are both device operations.
  * A and B are both host operations.
  * A is a device operation, B is a host operation, and the implementation
    supports concurrent host- and device-atomics.

NOTE: If two atomic operations are not mutually-ordered, then each must: be
synchronized against the other as if it were a non-atomic operation.

[[memory-model-scoped-modification-order]]
== Scoped Modification Order

For a given atomic operation A, all atomic operations that are
mutually-ordered with A occur in an order known as A's _scoped modification
order_.

NOTE: Invocations outside the instance of A's memory scope may: observe the
values at A's set of memory locations becoming visible to it in an order
that disagrees with the scoped modification order.

NOTE: It is valid to have non-atomic operations or atomics in a different
scope instance to the same set of memory locations, as long as they are
synchronized against each other as if they were non-atomic (if they are not,
it is treated as a <<memory-model-access-data-race,data race>>).
That means this definition of A's scoped modification order could include
atomic operations that occur much later, after intervening non-atomics.
That is a bit non-intuitive, but it helps to keep this definition simple and
non-circular.

[[memory-model-memory-semantics]]
== Memory Semantics

Non-atomic memory operations, by default, may: be observed by one agent in a
different order than they were written by another agent.

Atomics and some synchronization operations include _memory semantics_,
which are flags that constrain the order in which other memory accesses
(including non-atomic memory accesses and
<<memory-model-availability-visibility,availability and visibility
operations>>) performed by the same agent can: be observed by other agents,
or can: observe accesses by other agents.

Device instructions that include semantics are code:OpAtomic*,
code:OpControlBarrier, code:OpMemoryBarrier, and code:OpMemoryNamedBarrier.
Host instructions that include semantics are some std::atomic methods and
memory fences.

SPIR-V supports the following memory semantics:

  * Relaxed: No constraints on order of other memory accesses.
  * Acquire: A memory read with this semantic performs an _acquire
    operation_.
    A memory barrier with this semantic is an _acquire barrier_.
  * Release: A memory write with this semantic performs a _release
    operation_.
    A memory barrier with this semantic is a _release barrier_.
  * AcquireRelease: A memory read-modify-write operation with this semantic
    performs both an acquire operation and a release operation, and inherits
    the limitations on ordering from both of those operations.
    A memory barrier with this semantic is both a release and acquire
    barrier.

NOTE: SPIR-V does not support "consume" semantics on the device.

The memory semantics operand also includes _storage class semantics_ which
indicate which storage classes are constrained by the synchronization.
SPIR-V storage class semantics include:

  * UniformMemory
  * WorkgroupMemory
  * ImageMemory
  * OutputMemoryKHR

Each SPIR-V memory operation accesses a single storage class.
Semantics in synchronization operations can include a combination of storage
classes.

The UniformMemory storage class semantic applies to accesses to memory in
the Uniform and StorageBuffer storage classes.
The WorkgroupMemory storage class semantic applies to accesses to memory in
the Workgroup storage class.
The ImageMemory storage class semantic applies to accesses to memory in the
Image storage class.
The OutputMemoryKHR storage class semantic applies to accesses to memory in
the Output storage class.

NOTE: Informally, these constraints limit how memory operations can be
reordered, and these limits apply not only to the order of accesses as
performed in the agent that executes the instruction, but also to the order
the effects of writes become visible to all other agents within the same
instance of the instruction's memory scope.

NOTE: Release and acquire operations in different threads can: act as
synchronization operations, to guarantee that writes that happened before
the release are visible after the acquire.
(This is not a formal definition, just an informative forward reference.)

NOTE: The OutputMemoryKHR storage class semantic is only useful in
tessellation control shaders, which is the only execution model where output
variables are shared between invocations.

The memory semantics operand also optionally includes availability and
visibility flags, which apply availability and/or visibility operations as
described in <<memory-model-availability-visibility,availability and
visibility>>.
The availability/visibility flags are:

  * MakeAvailable: Semantics must: be Release or AcquireRelease.
    Performs an availability operation before the release operation or
    barrier.
  * MakeVisible: Semantics must: be Acquire or AcquireRelease.
    Performs a visibility operation after the acquire operation or barrier.

The specifics of these operations are defined in
<<memory-model-availability-visibility-semantics,Availability and Visibility
Semantics>>.

Host atomic operations may: support a different list of memory semantics and
synchronization operations, depending on the host architecture and source
language.

[[memory-model-release-sequence]]
== Release Sequence

After an atomic operation A performs a release operation on a set of memory
locations M, the _release sequence headed by A_ is the longest continuous
subsequence of A's scoped modification order that consists of:

  * the atomic operation A as its first element
  * atomic read-modify-write operations on M by any agent

NOTE: The atomics in the last bullet must: be mutually-ordered with A by
virtue of being in A's scoped modification order.

NOTE: This intentionally omits "atomic writes to M performed by the same
agent that performed A", which is present in the corresponding C++
definition.

[[memory-model-synchronizes-with]]
== Synchronizes-With

_Synchronizes-with_ is a relation between atomic operations and/or memory
barriers (aka fences on the host).

If A and B are atomic operations, then A synchronizes-with B if and only if
all of the following are true:

  * A performs a release operation
  * B performs an acquire operation
  * A and B are mutually-ordered
  * B takes its value from the release sequence headed by A

code:OpControlBarrier, code:OpMemoryBarrier, and code:OpMemoryNamedBarrier
are _memory barrier_ instructions in SPIR-V.

If A is a release barrier and B is an atomic operation that performs an
acquire operation, then A synchronizes-with B if and only if all of the
following are true:

  * there exists an atomic write X (with any memory semantics)
  * A is program-ordered before X
  * X and B are mutually-ordered
  * B reads the value written by X (or the release sequence headed by X, if
    X has release semantics)
  * A and B are in the instance of each other's memory scopes
  * X's storage class is in A's semantics.

If A is an atomic operation that performs a release operation and B is an
acquire barrier, then A synchronizes-with B if and only if all of the
following are true:

  * there exists an atomic read X (with any memory semantics)
  * X is program-ordered before B
  * X and A are mutually-ordered
  * X reads the value written by A (or the release sequence headed by A)
  * A and B are in the instance of each other's memory scopes
  * X's storage class is in B's semantics.

If A is a release barrier and B is an acquire barrier, then A
synchronizes-with B if all of the following are true:

  * there exists an atomic write X (with any memory semantics)
  * A is program-ordered before X
  * there exists an atomic read Y (with any memory semantics)
  * Y is program-ordered before B
  * X and Y are mutually-ordered
  * Y reads the value written by X (or the release sequence headed by X, if
    X has release semantics)
  * A and B are in the instance of each other's memory scopes
  * X's and Y's storage class is in A's and B's semantics.
  ** NOTE: X and Y must have the same storage class, because they are
     mutually ordered.

If A is a release barrier and B is an acquire barrier and C is a control
barrier (where A can optionally equal C and/or B can optionally equal C),
then A synchronizes-with B if all of the following are true:

  * A is program-ordered before (or equals) C
  * C is program-ordered before (or equals) B
  * A and B are in the instance of each other's memory scopes
  * A and B are in the instance of C's execution scope

NOTE: This is similar to the barrier-barrier synchronization above, but with
a control barrier filling the role of the relaxed atomics.

No other release and acquire barriers synchronize-with each other.

[[memory-model-system-synchronizes-with]]
== System-Synchronizes-With

_System-synchronizes-with_ is a relation between arbitrary operations on the
device or host.
Certain operations system-synchronize-with each other, which informally
means the first operation occurs before the second and that the
synchronization is performed without using application-visible memory
accesses.

If there is an <<synchronization-dependencies-execution,execution
dependency>> between two operations A and B, then the operation in the first
synchronization scope system-synchronizes-with the operation in the second
synchronization scope.

NOTE: This covers all Vulkan synchronization primitives, including device
operations executing before a synchronization primitive is signaled, wait
operations happening before subsequent device operations, signal operations
happening before host operations that wait on them, and host operations
happening before vkQueueSubmit.
The list is spread throughout the synchronization chapter, and is not
repeated here.

System-synchronizes-with implicitly includes all storage class semantics and
has code:CrossDevice scope.

If A system-synchronizes-with B, we also say A is
_system-synchronized-before_ B and B is _system-synchronized-after_ A.

[[memory-model-non-private]]
== Private vs. Non-Private

By default, non-atomic memory operations are treated as _private_, meaning
such a memory operation is not intended to be used for communication with
other agents.
Memory operations with the NonPrivatePointerKHR/NonPrivateTexelKHR bit set
are treated as _non-private_, and are intended to be used for communication
with other agents.

More precisely, for private memory operations to be
<<memory-model-location-ordered,Location-Ordered>> between distinct agents
requires using system-synchronizes-with rather than shader-based
synchronization.
Non-private memory operations still obey program-order.

Atomic operations are always considered non-private.

[[memory-model-inter-thread-happens-before]]
== Inter-Thread-Happens-Before

Let SC be a non-empty set of storage class semantics.
Then (using template syntax) operation A _inter-thread-happens-before_<SC>
operation B if and only if any of the following is true:

  * A system-synchronizes-with B
  * A synchronizes-with B, and both A and B have all of SC in their
    semantics
  * A is an operation on memory in a storage class in SC or that has all of
    SC in its semantics, B is a release barrier or release atomic with all
    of SC in its semantics, and A is program-ordered before B
  * A is an acquire barrier or acquire atomic with all of SC in its
    semantics, B is an operation on memory in a storage class in SC or that
    has all of SC in its semantics, and A is program-ordered before B
  * A and B are both host operations and A inter-thread-happens-before B as
    defined in the host language spec
  * A inter-thread-happens-before<SC> some X and X
    inter-thread-happens-before<SC> B

[[memory-model-happens-before]]
== Happens-Before

Operation A _happens-before_ operation B if and only if any of the following
is true:

  * A is program-ordered before B
  * A inter-thread-happens-before<SC> B for some set of storage classes SC

_Happens-after_ is defined similarly.

NOTE: Unlike C++, happens-before is not always sufficient for a write to be
visible to a read.
Additional <<memory-model-availability-visibility,availability and
visibility>> operations may: be required for writes to be
<<memory-model-visible-to,visible-to>> other memory accesses.

NOTE: Happens-before is not transitive, but each of program-order and
inter-thread-happens-before<SC> are transitive.
These can be thought of as covering the "single-threaded" case and the
"multi-threaded" case, and it's not necessary (and not valid) to form chains
between the two.

[[memory-model-availability-visibility]]
== Availability and Visibility

_Availability_ and _visibility_ are states of a write operation, which
(informally) track how far the write has permeated the system, i.e. which
agents and references are able to observe the write.
Availability state is per _memory domain_.
Visibility state is per (agent,reference) pair.
Availability and visibility states are per-memory location for each write.

Memory domains are named according to the agents whose memory accesses use
the domain.
Domains used by shader invocations are organized hierarchically into
multiple smaller memory domains which correspond to the different
<<memory-model-scope, scopes>>.
The memory domains defined in Vulkan include:

  * _host_ - accessible by host agents
  * _device_ - accessible by all device agents for a particular device
  * _shader_ - accessible by shader agents for a particular device,
    corresponding to the code:Device scope
  * _queue family instance_ - accessible by shader agents in a single queue
    family, corresponding to the code:QueueFamilyKHR scope.
  * _workgroup instance_ - accessible by shader agents in the same
    workgroup, corresponding to the code:Workgroup scope.
  * _subgroup instance_ - accessible by shader agents in the same subgroup,
    corresponding to the code:Subgroup scope.

NOTE: These do not correspond to storage classes or device-local and
host-local VkDeviceMemory allocations, rather they indicate whether a write
can be made visible only to agents in the same subgroup, same workgroup, in
any shader invocation, or anywhere on the device, or host.
The shader, queue family instance, workgroup instance, and subgroup instance
domains are only used for shader-based availability/visibility operatons, in
other cases writes can be made available from/visible to the shader via the
device domain.

_Availability operations_, _visibility operations_, and _memory domain
operations_ alter the state of the write operations that happen-before them,
and which are included in their _source scope_ to be available or visible to
their _destination scope_.

  * For an availability operation, the source scope is a set of
    (agent,reference,memory location) tuples, and the destination scope is a
    set of memory domains.
  * For a memory domain operation, the source scope is a memory domain and
    the destination scope is a memory domain.
  * For a visibility operation, the source scope is a set of memory domains
    and the destination scope is a set of (agent,reference,memory location)
    tuples.

How the scopes are determined depends on the specific operation.
Availability and memory domain operations expand the set of memory domains
to which the write is available.
Visibility operations expand the set of (agent,reference,memory location)
tuples to which the write is visible.

Recall that availability and visibility states are per-memory location, and
let W be a write operation to one or more locations performed by agent A via
reference R. Let L be one of the locations written.
(W,L) (the write W to L), is initially not available to any memory domain
and only visible to (A,R,L).
An availability operation AV that happens-after W and that includes (A,R,L)
in its source scope makes (W,L) _available_ to the memory domains in its
destination scope.

A memory domain operation DOM that happens-after AV and for which (W,L) is
available in the source scope makes (W,L) available in the destination
memory domain.

A visibility operation VIS that happens-after AV (or DOM) and for which
(W,L) is available in any domain in the source scope makes (W,L) _visible_
to all (agent,reference,L) tuples included in its destination scope.

If write W~2~ happens-after W, and their sets of memory locations overlap,
then W will not be available/visible to all agents/references for those
memory locations that overlap (and future AV/DOM/VIS ops can't revive W's
write to those locations).

Availability, memory domain, and visibility operations are treated like
other non-atomic memory accesses for the purpose of
<<memory-model-memory-semantics,memory semantics>>, meaning they can be
ordered by release-acquire sequences or memory barriers.

[[memory-model-vulkan-availability-visibility]]
== Availability, Visibility, and Domain Operations

The following operations generate availability, visibility, and domain
operations.
When multiple availability/visibility/domain operations are described, they
are system-synchronized-with each other in the order listed.

An operation that performs a <<synchronization-dependencies-memory,memory
dependency>> generates:

  * If the source access mask includes ename:VK_ACCESS_HOST_WRITE_BIT, then
    the dependency includes a memory domain operation from host domain to
    device domain.
  * An availability operation with source scope of all writes in the first
    <<synchronization-dependencies-access-scopes,access scope>> of the
    dependency and a destination scope of the device domain.
  * A visibility operation with source scope of the device domain and
    destination scope of the second access scope of the dependency.
  * If the destination access mask includes ename:VK_ACCESS_HOST_READ_BIT or
    ename:VK_ACCESS_HOST_WRITE_BIT, then the dependency includes a memory
    domain operation from device domain to host domain.

flink:vkFlushMappedMemoryRanges performs an availability operation, with a
source scope of (agents,references) = (all host threads, all mapped memory
ranges passed to the command), and destination scope of the host domain.

flink:vkInvalidateMappedMemoryRanges performs a visibility operation, with a
source scope of the host domain and a destination scope of
(agents,references) = (all host threads, all mapped memory ranges passed to
the command).

flink:vkQueueSubmit performs a memory domain operation from host to device,
and a visibility operation with source scope of the device domain and
destination scope of all agents and references on the device.

[[memory-model-availability-visibility-semantics]]
== Availability and Visibility Semantics

A memory barrier or atomic operation via agent A that includes MakeAvailable
in its semantics performs an availability operation whose source scope
includes agent A and all references in the storage classes in that
instruction's storage class semantics, and all memory locations, and whose
destination scope is a set of memory domains selected as specified below.
The implicit availability operation is program-ordered between the barrier
or atomic and all other operations program-ordered before the write.

A memory barrier or atomic operation via agent A that includes MakeVisible
in its semantics performs a visibility operation whose source scope is a set
of memory domains selected as specified below, and whose destination scope
includes agent A and all references in the storage classes in that
instruction's storage class semantics, and all memory locations.
The implicit visibility operation is program-ordered between the barrier or
atomic and all other operations program-ordered after the write.

The memory domains are selected based on the memory scope of the instruction
as follows:

  * code:Device scope uses the shader domain
  * code:QueueFamilyKHR scope uses the queue family instance domain
  * code:Workgroup scope uses the workgroup instance domain
  * code:Subgroup uses the subgroup instance domain
  * code:Invocation perform no availability/visibility operations.

When an availability operation performed by an agent A includes a memory
domain D in its destination scope, where D corresponds to scope instance S,
it also includes the memory domains that correspond to each smaller scope
instance S' that is a subset of S and that includes A. Similarly for
visibility operations.

[[memory-model-instruction-av-vis]]
== Per-Instruction Availability and Visibility Semantics

A memory write instruction that includes MakePointerAvailable, or an image
write instruction that includes MakeTexelAvailable, performs an availability
operation whose source scope includes the agent and reference used to
perform the write and the memory locations written by the instruction, and
whose destination scope is a set of memory domains selected by the Scope
operand specified in <<memory-model-availability-visibility-semantics,
Availability and Visibility Semantics>>.
The implicit availability operation is program-ordered between the write and
all other operations program-ordered after the write.

A memory read instruction that includes MakePointerVisible, or an image read
instruction that includes MakeTexelVisible, performs a visibility operation
whose source scope is a set of memory domains selected by the Scope operand
as specified in <<memory-model-availability-visibility-semantics,
Availability and Visibility Semantics>>, and whose destination scope
includes the agent and reference used to perform the read and the memory
locations read by the instruction.
The implicit visibility operation is program-ordered between read and all
other operations program-ordered before the read.

NOTE: Although reads with per-instruction visibility only perform visibility
ops from the shader or workgroup instance or subgroup instance domain, they
will also see writes that were made visible via the device domain, i.e.
those writes previously performed by non-shader agents and made visible via
API commands.

NOTE: It is expected that all invocations in a subgroup execute on the same
processor with the same path to memory, and thus availability and visibility
operations with subgroup scope can be expected to be "free".

[[memory-model-location-ordered]]
== Location-Ordered

Let X and Y be memory accesses to overlapping sets of memory locations M,
where X != Y. Let (A~X~,R~X~) be the agent and reference used for X, and
(A~Y~,R~Y~) be the agent and reference used for Y. For now, let "->" denote
happens-before and "->^rcpo^" denote the reflexive closure of
program-ordered before.

If D~1~ and D~2~ are different memory domains, then let DOM(D~1~,D~2~) be a
memory domain operation from D~1~ to D~2~.
Otherwise, let DOM(D,D) be a placeholder such that X->DOM(D,D)->Y if and
only if X->Y.

X is _location-ordered_ before Y for a location L in M if and only if any of
the following is true:

  * A~X~ == A~Y~ and R~X~ == R~Y~ and X->Y
  ** NOTE: this case means no availability/visibility ops required when it's
     the same (agent,reference).
  * X and Y are mutually-ordered atomics, and X is before Y in X's scoped
    modification order

  * X is a read, both X and Y are non-private, and X->Y
  * X is a read, and X (transitively) system-synchronizes with Y

  * If R~X~ == R~Y~ and A~X~ and A~Y~ access a common memory domain D (e.g.
    are in the same workgroup instance if D is the workgroup instance
    domain), and both X and Y are non-private:
  ** X is a write, Y is a write, AV(A~X~,R~X~,D,L) is an availability
     operation making (X,L) available to domain D, and
     X->^rcpo^AV(A~X~,R~X~,D,L)->Y
  ** X is a write, Y is a read, AV(A~X~,R~X~,D,L) is an availability
     operation making (X,L) available to domain D, VIS(A~Y~,R~Y~,D,L) is a
     visibility operation making writes to L available in domain D visible
     to Y, and X->^rcpo^AV(A~X~,R~X~,D,L)->VIS(A~Y~,R~Y~,D,L)->^rcpo^Y

  * Let D~X~ and D~Y~ each be either the device domain or the host domain,
    depending on whether A~X~ and A~Y~ execute on the device or host:
  ** X is a write and Y is a write, and
     X->AV(A~X~,R~X~,D~X~,L)->DOM(D~X~,D~Y~)->Y
  ** X is a write and Y is a read, and
     X->AV(A~X~,R~X~,D~X~,L)->DOM(D~X~,D~Y~)->VIS(A~Y~,R~Y~,D~Y~,L)->Y

NOTE: The final bullet (synchronization through device/host domain) requires
API-level synchronization operations, since the device/host domains are not
accessible via shader instructions.
And "device domain" is not to be confused with "device scope", which
synchronizes through the "shader domain".

[[memory-model-access-data-race]]
== Data Race

Let X and Y be operations that access overlapping sets of memory locations
M, where X != Y, and at least one of X and Y is a write, and X and Y are not
mutually-ordered atomic operations.
If there does not exist a location-ordered relation between X and Y for each
location in M, then there is a _data race_.

Applications must: ensure that no data races occur during the execution of
their application.

NOTE: Data races can only occur due to instructions that are actually
executed, and for example an instruction skipped due to flow control must
not contribute to a data race.

[[memory-model-visible-to]]
== Visible-To

Let X be a write and Y be a read whose sets of memory locations overlap, and
let M be the set of memory locations that overlap.
Let M~2~ be a non-empty subset of M. Then X is _visible-to_ Y for memory
locations M~2~ if and only if all of the following are true:

  * X is location-ordered before Y for each location L in M~2~.
  * There does not exist another write Z to any location L in M~2~ such that
    X is location-ordered before Z for location L and Z is location-ordered
    before Y for location L.

If X is visible-to Y, then Y reads the value written by X for locations
M~2~.

NOTE: It is possible for there to be a write between X and Y that overwrites
a subset of the memory locations, but the remaining memory locations (M~2~)
will still be visible-to Y.

[[memory-model-scoped-modification-order-coherence]]
== Scoped Modification Order Coherence

Let A and B be mutually-ordered atomic operations, where A happens-before B,
and let O be A's scoped modification order.
Then:

  * If A and B are both writes, then A must: be earlier than B in O
  * If A and B are both reads, then the write that A takes its value from
    must: be earlier in O than (or the same as) the write that B takes its
    value from
  * If A is a write and B is a read, then B must: take its value from A or a
    write later than A in O
  * If A is a read and B is a write, then A must: take its value from a
    write earlier than B in O

[[memory-model-shader-io]]
== Shader I/O

If a shader invocation A in a shader stage other than code:Vertex performs a
memory read operation X from an object in the code:Input storage class, then
X is system-synchronized-after all writes to the corresponding code:Output
storage variable(s) in the upstream shader invocation(s) that contribute to
generating invocation A, and those writes are all visible-to X.

NOTE: It is not necessary for the upstream shader invocations to have
completed execution, they only need to have generated the output that is
being read.

[[memory-model-deallocation]]
== Deallocation

A call to vkFreeMemory must: happen-after all memory operations on all
memory locations in that VkDeviceMemory object.

NOTE: Normally, device memory operations in a given queue are synchronized
with vkFreeMemory by having a host thread wait on a fence signalled by that
queue, and the wait happens-before the call to vkFreeMemory on the host.

The deallocation of SPIR-V variables is managed by the system and
happens-after all operations on those variables.

[[memory-model-informative-descriptions]]
== Informative Descriptions

This subsection is non-normative, and offers more easily understandable
consequences of the memory model for app/compiler developers.

Let SC be the storage class(es) specified by a release or acquire operation
or barrier.

  * An atomic write with release semantics must not be reordered against any
    read or write to SC that is program-ordered before it (regardless of the
    storage class the atomic is in).

  * An atomic read with acquire semantics must not be reordered against any
    read or write to SC that is program-ordered after it (regardless of the
    storage class the atomic is in).

  * Any write to SC program-ordered after a release barrier must not be
    reordered against any read or write to SC program-ordered before that
    barrier.

  * Any read from SC program-ordered before an acquire barrier must not be
    reordered against any read or write to SC program-ordered after the
    barrier.

A control barrier (even if it has no memory semantics) must not be reordered
against any memory barriers.

This memory model allows memory accesses with and without availability and
visibility operations, as well as atomic operations, all to be performed on
the same memory location.
This is critical to allow it to reason about memory that is reused in
multiple ways, e.g. across the lifetime of different shader invocations or
draw calls.
While GLSL (and legacy SPIR-V) applies the "coherent" decoration to
variables (for historical reasons), this model treats each memory access
instruction as having optional implicit availability/visibility operations.
GLSL to SPIR-V compilers should map all (non-atomic) operations on a
coherent variable to Make{Pointer,Texel}{Available}{Visible} flags in this
model.

Atomic operations implicitly have availability/visibility operations, and
the scope of those operations is taken from the atomic operation's scope.

[[memory-model-tessellation-output-ordering]]
== Tessellation Output Ordering

For SPIR-V that uses the Vulkan Memory Model, the code:OutputMemory storage
class is used to synchronize accesses to tessellation control output
variables.
For legacy SPIR-V that does not enable the Vulkan Memory Model via
code:OpMemoryModel, tessellation outputs can be ordered using a control
barrier with no particular memory scope or semantics, as defined below.

Let X and Y be memory operations performed by shader invocations A~X~ and
A~Y~.
Operation X is _tessellation-output-ordered_ before operation Y if and only
if all of the following are true:

  * There is a dynamic instance of an code:OpControlBarrier instruction C
    such that X is program-ordered before C in A~X~ and C is program-ordered
    before Y in A~Y~.
  * A~X~ and A~Y~ are in the same instance of C's execution scope.

If shader invocations A~X~ and A~Y~ in the code:TessellationControl
execution model execute memory operations X and Y, respectively, on the
code:Output storage class, and X is tessellation-output-ordered before Y
with a scope of code:Workgroup, then X is location-ordered before Y, and if
X is a write and Y is a read then X is visible-to Y.